HomeMy WebLinkAboutRe_ Resubmission of Joint Response to Appellants Motion to DismissALERT: BE CAUTIOUS This email originated outside the organization. Do not open attachments or click on links if you are not expecting them.
Ariel and Jesse, If you file a new version of the "same" document, please label it in the title as "Corrected" or "Amended." Otherwise, there are two documents with the same name but
with different text, when they should instead carry distinct titles. (This sort of confusion is an issue in this case.)
It is also best to file it in "redline," so a reader can see where changes have been made. (Is it the word "erroneous"?)
In searching back and forth between versions, I see that the word "County" is misspelled at the top of the first page, and the date of "August 15, 2025" in the first paragraph is erroneous--on
both documents. I am not suggesting you file another version, but if you do, please label it "Second Corrected . . ." I'm also not objecting to untimely filing of the second document
you submitted.
Adiel and Carolyn, please forward this email to the Hearing Examiner, in hopes that he might consider directing that different documents carry different titles, and if a later document
is a correction of an earlier version, the later one should be filed in redline.
I am glad you appropriately filed both documents in the online casefile.
Thank you--Marilyn
Marilyn Showalter
1596 Shine Rd
Port Ludlow, WA 98365
(360) 259-1700 (cell)
marilyn.showalter@gmail.com <mailto:marilyn.showalter@gmail.com>
On Wed, Jul 23, 2025 at 9:42 AM Ariel Speser <ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us> > wrote:
Thank you, Adiel. Confirming receipt.
Sincerely,
Ariel Speser
Civil Deputy Prosecuting Attorney
aspeser@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:aspeser@co.jefferson.wa.us>
Phone: 360.385.9180
Fax: 360.385.9186
NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY:
This communication (and any attachments) is for the attorney of record for the individual named in the subject line of this email. It is privileged and confidential. If you are not
the person or entity for whom it is intended, or a representative thereof, you are hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If
you have received this communication in error, please reply immediately and delete this message and any copy from your inbox and backup systems. Thank you.
From: Adiel F. McKnight <AFMcKnight@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:AFMcKnight@co.jefferson.wa.us> >
Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 9:19 AM
To: Laura Mikelson <LMikelson@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:LMikelson@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; Carolyn Gallaway <carolyn@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:carolyn@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; jesse@plauchecarr.com
<mailto:jesse@plauchecarr.com> ; Ariel Speser <ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; marilyn.showalter@gmail.com <mailto:marilyn.showalter@gmail.com>
Subject: RE: Resubmission of Joint Response to Appellants Motion to Dismiss
Received, thank you Laura,
Updated exhibit log for Rock Island Shellfish. I have forwarded to Hearing Examiner and am updating the hearing page.
Adiel
Adiel McKnight
Deputy Clerk of the Board, CMC
P.O. Box 1220
Port Townsend, WA 98368
360.385.9102
This is a reminder that all email to or from this email address may be subject to the Public Records Act contained in RCW 42.56. Additionally, all email to and from the county is captured
and archived by Information Services.
From: Laura Mikelson <LMikelson@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:LMikelson@co.jefferson.wa.us> >
Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 8:08 AM
To: Adiel F. McKnight <AFMcKnight@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:AFMcKnight@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; Carolyn Gallaway <carolyn@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:carolyn@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; jesse@plauchecarr.c
om <mailto:jesse@plauchecarr.com> ; Ariel Speser <ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us <mailto:ASpeser@co.jefferson.wa.us> >; marilyn.showalter@gmail.com <mailto:marilyn.showalter@gmail.com>
Subject: Resubmission of Joint Response to Appellants Motion to Dismiss
Thank you Adiel for alerting me that we had a scriveners error in the title. Please see the attached corrected version.
Laura Mikelson
Paralegal Lead, Civil Department
Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office
P.O. Box 1220, Port Townsend, WA 98368
Ph: 360-385-9181 Fax: 360-385-9186
All e-mail sent to this address has been received by the Jefferson County e-mail system and is therefore subject to the Public Records Act, a state law found at RCW 42.56. Under the
Public Records law the County must release this e-mail and its contents to any person who asks to obtain a copy (or for inspection) of this e-mail unless it is also exempt from production
to the requester according to state law, including RCW 42.56 and other state laws.
繃褓䘹낭魿莀ồ෮ﵟᚆꥁ瀏⮸뢜念篁觮冥熌ȕ碎瞳㞾羽ủ믾ꓨ훍뫊볯뫡ಸբ蕓裣鲪쉉灤窬ᣔﳬ鹏긿괻衲�詶썓胣䠧蚐⁹鶋ﯻ엟軖늾�洫狔䒖﹐凝ⳁ፲㱹クㆽꘗ㽹죿䄖맮祯ᑇ朇�鼾哾同ほ鶋⳪绥頸蹭ⰹ쬞㼘�ौ▕ꉬ䚢ફ燓頲븷堠䖎䶎췰笱倠㟚뗾ﱿ䖭쁔훶魜꘠焹판찦㢟矴�燮气矋ᆾᨏ轲遥灅䛊纽⸌⾆뇕㜕湺㵺숴墫⽂⽔宺悩ᯆ쳹正�饸膊Ꮕ肖瑜ῴ⤣䥁껾溛浬媓葉挎牷莄鸼⠝㚛ᐐ䫡䵨
⒬鴫덩痨␋⭱岖镹ﵬ뱗幦ꕥቕ淿灤릓㸵⭊諒䱔된瀼鸔䭻뽇퍜蕷Ꮐ궉顗㻏럻િ漿⮥둭䃉ウ蓗搠矗▼䦾荹킬撹ꗢ䠮滝�渏鳝ꠑ譪�濳乸憍뺺㾥㘊챑薷莛쓉뵇⪚躣뻊᎑⇚ﭵ峲㊣Ӕश읆䉽逬㽇黏鳵쫾荩⌂룶䒊娠쒏ᔃﰻ㮾쳬㞾ꨲ儉း䵥㲜႒媂㠻参뙾๛輊퉃饔溲㌠⏨䇎᧙ﳾ�笟ﻼㆷ댛䱽샛擞ܜኒ鎢뉑띵⻝擶藻ẑ㷦믞箳뵮㨥谜黄첫璓튬䳫悀⥑柙髠繚柽퓺릐齞ᴭ딜띒鲤柙쥄볓㉊仾鼊綟⓭獸ẘ涰澞
䢫ࡕ뻺铢抓궆茊墤諴쌻ﳧ랹↼옲ꁋ�긾⠺ⰸ�棢㘯㚺ᝇ魞癞骙굕䆋オ九쵻뉠닭糲┛瞨볙籕柮�堬뵉⩃颋崳ꥬ능罝륬改璂排規䈋䷈얘轢犴툲趗๘他㶽퐙ឍ顝ﭝ펷ꥣ阽搫綇虀鑥岋ꃩ쁔똲펚뗫瑪石叿굼䱈屷畷ᥬ뜬㫦헙私햓翔�夘ແ폰ﰏ硉ở궋紁蹛眤曂ㅶ놥掉僼齸믯컬껫閍䩯㗢鏮跠䙪ꥹ籷䠡黒鬰⠯븱捇ᶾ柞̜祣﹘릂࠲蹬毝ὅ䣸䗬飵뼽�늻뾑몀ﳾ뉳ﻫ䙶ዜ朷䷣遃䆱㻸�钹y軯콯㲮슟⓲㍼Ꮨ뫬뇁と묙䠲倪뗰
읈ꘙﺜ疳ɳ疴ⴅ�鴰냵봷�苴蟒倞㠻൪㉤펣ĉ翏溷脾坥螋榃䂘䋀�췸ꗥ꧱①侓ވ䏚룿阿閛촼廝玱囿壷鵮답彵菊হﭠ큒漍ᛍ載깫퇻壠碷蟟篢뼡ᯫ諭ᛏḩ/됡켩�넪쩳ݚ셓⳽�頱݊鐈훴탵כ晃됪丫ㅾ쉨盦čꮇ娺癗웅矶白솮꿅㣔逹蕌貸볦뎳컫⬾슖뷵磗雑庵꺗꾕�윹⺗둒ࣤꛗ㼙둠뗊䴃峌䰑䊹ꌢ跇璳け뮎藻ꌂ娅襁敳�密퀾�槓뛋῭ꬭ紫�娧䜷搊ཊ�肜կ壻슴⧧騘픤�齦짽�熂檼㠸ﯡ䕻탇�隕嗴ᄃ
묵搴廪燁্站㯞㮌뾮ꗹ�ි뿫뗪羱ᴽ�캳躈媝ꨒầꏰ券懄ꎐ赔쓠툑�덤謸ꤻ⫬ປᾯ崫ደ�뷍䜇죰༃嗄纐畚垪풻喜▲徖똱蘟같ኌ�Ꝧ梕碶߯�ῶ�̙巉잏䟊娿껢ᯩ㸯졻襺�淍�ꬲ㺮鵯嵬啐�繿㬢惮瑾ဒ彤갔ᛎጆ瀈䗌ꌨꖓ䣊欥檦ෆ⍕頋ꨗ趟㩣㚝予뜐낊䀁솩쩚腑듞ꬱ짢㧯㥒锘ൾ쫆솑⤦氻얰늋籏ﯯ鏙飣㾧㎈ᯙꦿ㴦ꯇ㭏㨹餭麡搖Ხᔜ㘆⽖㘇㠕⑪御쾭�䜉糘梑퇄◢㷙�ᰐ꿉睜曺趐ᇟ묜쿟✻扊렢넭䫢浑륋選丹
䆸ῄ㝼�杽ꇜ톾�뭜ⳃⳂ᱾㰃負뫧ৎ䵭ﵟ癲坋彠䰗셉뫏쯠睊雸ꕠ䠶듔郰끬뗋읁灅串䁅㙒剞賷䝻띌雓⤺钕ꢝ⭃琷Ἁ饊뺈開䂈倯䈲卤樶ᑢ퍂쨞፩꾶㻌췺ᛊպ㌥덛�䰦葑꿒鵑꽛Ⲽ믮罣晐╍ᶪ킲치昌嗎試宽ᤅ髪湛궝苾踗횄罯ḽ擖⧓튵燊뾊邞垲Ʉ칒깶눓뵱믝陂퍷ᜥ病冤竿❆谲懫↺멈죠쟟梀឵㙈蟫ຖ岉骢헷洵Ȓ뵛凩�潽激溔폆䮢�葃줨�㋃㇟㣘枬檮ꫧ桘⋧ད팅듭⥁沼뫑鷆࠾�썴行ꋠḘ쀓쟗ᗩ尮�擄旊ړ肇⓯퍍�
雴䈁ϴ驿⾹⏌憚�썐뷨컿ꨡ護崭ﲶ�ゥ샶睝ᇆܚሮ系㈻譭览祁真恔ݩ⓾渺�໓凸ꀤ㱙̢ᘞ各嶷䕹됤䋉ꞽ旄䫒집湐䌦ꝋꜞ酠隥힉ﷱ��ﭿ燭謴빮३㿄Ǔ峏药蕬黵愽眏㣓胪暟�拕䦩�諵뵠䄓莚퍳鄔㐹侉�檰珄鶃갚ⶌ+紩鯓⣂洸꣬菋즕见黄琐㺞紐利闹ㇰ㷉绷樠봓㢉ᨏ㨀⾰⓪뗯㯍闟﮽뮳춸麪�ⶖ鸄遢ђⲤṙ콉唲
礅㇑詿寽䔎垏㠯옇ವ蜵럿囶䓛莌Ṿ쀜�嬺魯쭥壃ヘ崳ඕ븗쏯꧑諭厌䕢᧢걫甙閰�Ù⛗ὑカ렟黷鈨ᩃ�が퀐�Ⰻ墲渌尖텤᠘摝枙ꧫﯡ弴諏畺`撻聊葶哾햯懀䉀啁្✖周託◼�㕊楤靐赝펂ꈆ嗫幣퓾㦺逭揭ច問ꫭ봿糁ォ鬪昢땠サ㔦弰펹닻=㏣钍ţ꿈濼圜瑚撢择అ⸋逐溄림땳旗橖먒삊轎ᘅ훌ㅕ᠈㋵ᘯ燼罻똫阂罟훃ꚦ⮆䮊ຣ잺虅ꬂ垻쇅龡윛铴ॸ쓎횳龊䳡殃厍鵶꧙떎賿휵휎⫧䱱콏啟⣄⣖坟ḧ믺꽬
﹏摫ោ菀ೣᘺ༟㥆牒䨴ᴺ녒胶ጦ䪮誌䛓噩幾︡ᄶ죊ஈ�㧽�➷ീ降蠽ߊ衂㗲巐厷鬓া⥐竂㒟ﲘⁿﻛ錓ﻷז�圥㥚媎ɵᦂ絇姍쑧柃䶕ᾟ棇죊塒䣘빥䯦溷䝭ጚ㻘オ뜝秅滬Ꞵ苫奔韺潢◷堆煂῁켏襁뿨談銇긽沀囑ⴶ찲⼦��譂ᄭᏚ곋욺ᅄᆒ℆꼙潓뙟끵閐뀮ꋨ⩱蜁畂鶡㣴ᇫ文ﻟ辷칅ॄ얦ꨉ葩ၞ镻䟋ⶡ趪粉䂌著㚑쮡轮펊曲쫼灀咾뻩뱡�媯✷罀䌈ၻନ궽㍵䗂ꂀፙ踰ꓞ㧛㚓횉䷲仱莄賔똲鄸按㉉੫敖涽ﮙꞕ
Ნ쓬埥첈ᗲ�鰞熴�ి≿瀄觹旇Თ瑷ヌ搵讙뛇燆�긳钴扱㽞煣䦄컖᎙៤橞疻侪≚틆醔{‘䗔ᐐႌ秮黠扻�㵣콰酝杸묷덾逶㔥ᮮ떛소촵漜✚瘝챈⮰똜怪ە凂覅猡顪裚캺�욫쭹훰敠ꆾ豱펒犖탐팮쓜㏌㕪㕌⤝梄좯爎煑菦ཀ넇叾ꁂ태舦艕璚빚巢攻翴枅䄥툞톸�ᓯ읿얮Ꜩ괃쪷猹㐘ꮖ瓺Ⰴ悬莴쵺沗魕Ѭ齒郵ᢪẂ�嚖珼墶场䃱㞤懝胸ꂓ纑�辯茼笼⡽爸㲏述ᵸ쩱茞ꟼ浂῞玎퓥싱韅쵨㾗惸㲬⚸뾈鿄薹巟蠇艠䞁縞
⨰蓼ᱷವ轙䧹쿳鏮Ꭓ딭걌ࠤ枛섚ﻟ䩃宰柊䋍쇻뚩ƙຟ즕‱뼐疰┘ටꎕニ委肸甲봱㈖荽숈下⭕岸新腵莏橍淒눝糷翾拙魌횫붿釈顃㚾奲霔뼈셗ﴁ郗㨍༾襭ೆ뺆燌ώ㊊Ღꧢ_瑡⿈坸噋볿࿃滉ﲾ㭅处ﰰᡮᓽۆ崡䳹鮁鸌汿掮顾᰽붕ଞ㴿ᢿ࠴舆陣୍⣲떼뇶ỏ忋ﭤﹽ攳氽䛸늰鱩荱儹߁ꦦ䛐檢蒿�頖霺冄�ɀ沯锵䭨긖탇破夆ဴ몽ڐ�逖쨲쉦˫뫦쑖윤얽幫綗쯰赟䶙瀝Ự쾿阠孑䥓둎ꎓ䇎萜줨讂
阬潵喚썍䩪帽疊7俥בּ㸇ᴚ떨嚓湗︑ᆟᲦ鿗럷濸浆溤ﶰ짶韪ၣɓ虧掳¦䜗�躤ꛪ⑥胃⛥犜梨ꟴ峋䘓ኑ䒩呎墥樆쯼鬒沆�ꔬ掆夳િ䠾褐꫰唶⛸ꐊ좔粡젂㙽惯乆ڸ붮悸秠�ᚦ稫뇬덇⾛㢻墖ᗵ抧鹁�凁�槞Ꮻ䦩퐥▇`Ě꜐壀딝丶斞넥톲᫆퓇蜏콦䭻ﳙ촉鎁騦큲⨞ꗆ䲐ꊌ쀠퇳粎ぃϕ盙ﯓ輙礹櫟튫쳪᱄㚞ꊌ뻓ᠣ㚧虉䀳饿泳핒瑇ѧᶡꦜᓬ뱫ࠗ똼昊谫ற걬蜲ತ堤힘ᖩ푠⦠ᩢ몦퇷戗痂埕ᝥ皞궼즷媞⽃䣐㶖诇ﴬ�걧
Ẃ鴥㵮㬵ᎍ蟪젖譂뜝㉞鬪㼼윒漏绱幑앵鼍띯곖ᔚ烛㞻魌ﮆ앬辣鈾鿳ﻍ鸪⑮ᦝᶛ㡥䑣ໞ純魫桛⁴ᢧჽ∝憠䭪㛎␂⢍』埌䘎딶㺩篷ꦂ隆뭁�팵녇퐾茋䖕昻綛䶨됌ꢻᄏ灶鲞㝛麐쐚칗酱響흙臆춗줥ﵸ鯽濢蠭㻶찓ﴅﻏ䆠얘밢椰杶㖅閞橽斳⾖쒛෫ḗ䑵ﵶ枹孧녓夯☄冹잣噃㱮ᎌ﬩ॻ䋵岉岩菵蜹㛽쬲绗뛙ウ䡆渫↼碌武땯ᑭ䧊Ḙﰞﷇ黙?癨鿦麏⟻–゙凶㉌Ԇ⇜鲱崹᭧碓贔⸳慌㭮糿鶡荭녾ꞩ䋙䰚葁낤덬삎낁ﳋ쐇鼨颊䛎쪔ꅀ⪬ᨚ
쨄彋�ޜᓽ�鼖腗羳す鈗렒鴏㸳�良♙ᠢㅰ获캢솦�쒚婍뻬㏤춖뤾㦲ཫ豢⼛觊㥏缰㬯룱쫬麿ⶐ쪽酪Ჹ웙䌉숁㇗呪̀甊氛ዧ䅮ᾤ鏭ᶭ漲㜢쌉��綖ϵ쯯㼮羹IJ볦鱬�㈌鰀쨣鍦े逪톥齌쩐㲘�薂⏩馱ᑬ搹鳚럱ꂉꬅ剄뛧鈚諮反鱎ⷣ䤂ߍ〈ϖ↧쇲䍛䙧ג捵ᶮ큑ᗜ튱坑額㇠툭༷机疝趯뒍祄躓잟뼘撿胺蹗睝垛ᵅ蓮䇡涆હǎ㴯펕㻯䟹曻汫令ゞﰼ諽돋밯蝻㇈䄩�溲轾惰䙅츗⭟█❕菻䄁ୀ뻳鄬䰥鱕騤谶꙲騍
쉧닌�鮟깷랫ꬡ�쎷㦪✑筑靀厵⩛恂㋂퓤핥�朸悥⣍ﴏ稣Ꮿ汗㠅�Ό趟�苽㡣쟻鴱ệ㡹낌⻬視�皷鲋봂묌俊�釾᠈輷థ碞辭鋭翝⥷짟樟햽沬೭淬ﷹ솧艰藺鱳⤿欣טּ얕誯趿䘀槝貃흵췖ꡉѣ鐋辶�Ҥ㜋푤荘㱺賾횣雫坉佁앚ꫀ盌虠ऻ䎧怴证锬⟭ᜐႍ꽊ᮮ辮箎웎诏켚팉ꈏ율睾죷榤꾐튔蘒㾃ﳽ�マ흯퇬镲䤳ꒄꭁ溭ꘛ䘎匩摹왺枲㭦륧돩朳誧뾃㝇较뷯뿂劭ﮏ끔쭢婴ั뭎ᑓϤ쩓괩甡쐉弊抂훓萅⸭쨸닱
뵩滷絀㢬矓み㲃ꛧṤ㗱럱혂��粿㯫拙靋㗱옒쾴렺⍅랜禡皨ー怼鿮艌ཀྵ톤즺䁗Ⓢ⣗ⓧ䌹䉭潧䟑Ꮼ⤌+鎅䣤榝*쇈⭔␑ﯲ᷉猬誦牆鴇맿쬿磫몖攖糙톫굘콘摫ะꔨ㶗㉢ᝠ㽁翐뚦葖例蝿藓䍨矺鰪诬쯠ⓒᷰ㫬㊷ቯ纖쟙붿뙷꛶찤倄䍃尖◳謯삤컠湛盎죿뎇칋Ც뙁胧堪ጓ⨳쪈㓋궶㦐杲�Ⴡ㣅挸䪢ⓨ윾ᰝ纵윸葜胷⦴喟屡㚜Ῥꪬ�⎯ꏔ䶖틧虎췷⭉晴Õꦗ뢺⒋䆺ః嫰�⌏㐂븻끧酉叨堗笰껏鏿䖍䀪䉂㝂펌㶳
�㜝侷乼敄틫祺逍步쨍㬪ᎁᙷ⼘ﭳ셃טּٱ賽똯乮廂냁䟳들嘹낎鵌夃芀럱쇮죛㦦ඃ僢롳�岡钤ၰᨂ䷭붌䆕忏득띔쭲뼷�珩巿ႋ䉋泂蔀쎳롿꾋雭悔楈귬욚务᱐ဥ路け歬㊓맦ꉳ㣮㭁쳴칠⋓ຮ蒦高ᲃ谱펓갆㋪蜠ὑ헫竩ꏬ냸맕馊ﶂ샦�藰䪙볇ગ䩮홳❞韻栚Ⱜ愡6簫俯㉿ﴻ镏緛९忣濢ޣ뚙寭�펔㼥ˣ娬콕눲弭떠テ珊旚ꖐ⭒挫됖ॡ䰃尗瓌譫䮞悅�⋲�낻শలᙱ㯤ꅳ�鬒肙溻㖽ܷ䭥Ꮐሒ䌦坽�컟ﮚ錧ﬠ�
䵒唛汰澶㠒篁咡ә붫퀉ブ廧픆⏚熋듋䣁ꢒ沮ꀧ됒槨鬘쫀ꕠ瘦㭥樸ㄢյ阓�鷅팹Зᘛ�⌵ퟓ⨋屣⽦�쾊튅깖蒄␈䎿臨癮黐잻ᗛ�䟑괵⸲澰廚䈅穑嫜⍶噙ஞỚ柈㍥錇∐輡올槑튃臑鮭ₓ﮸鄥௵葁䁊晋菰鮭䌃؟폃壈〻⤹璔註ݖ⬰薍ક⾓뭃㵽獛㋣晢쉂쇬휭靟義⻏괼덲즤괔丮ᱻ迁슘馡ꕁ劒쒙푢䳻