HomeMy WebLinkAbout060126 email - Request_ Independent Safety Inspection of Port Townsend Paper Mill White Liquor Infrastructure — Post-LongviewALERT: BE CAUTIOUS This email originated outside the organization. Do not open attachments or click on links if you are not expecting them.
Dear Members of the Jefferson County Board of Commissioners,
I am copying members of the press on this letter intentionally. The matter I am raising is urgent, as it involves public safety, and the community deserves to know that it is being brought
to your attention. Note: your server rejected the email with the cc list
As of today, nine people are confirmed dead in Longview, with two more workers still missing and presumed dead. A 900,000-gallon tank of white liquor — the caustic chemical at the heart
of kraft paper production — imploded at the Nippon Dynawave mill on May 26th. Governor Ferguson has called it the deadliest industrial accident in modern Washington State history.
Port Townsend Paper Company runs the same process. Same chemical. Similar tanks. On 450 acres bordering Port Townsend Bay, less than two miles from our downtown, in a community of 10,000
people.
Port Townsend is a boating, fishing, arts, and tourism community. Our bay is not a backdrop — it is our economy, our identity, and our way of life.
A white liquor release into Port Townsend Bay would be catastrophic: caustic sodium hydroxide and sodium sulfide pouring into the waters where our fishing boats work, where kayakers
and sailors launch, where visitors come from across the region. The marine environment that supports our charter fishing industry, our boat yards, our waterfront businesses, and our
tourism economy could be devastated for years.
The 2025 spill of 114,000 gallons of untreated industrial wastewater into the bay — one of thirteen documented spills since 2013 — gives us a preview of what inadequate containment looks
like at this facility. A Longview-scale event would be an order of magnitude worse.
We also want to be clear: the 300 workers at Port Townsend Paper Company are our neighbors, our friends, and members of this community. They deserve to work in a facility with tanks
that have been inspected, maintained, and certified safe. The workers who died in Longview went to work that Tuesday morning expecting to come home. Protecting PTPC employees from that
fate is not in conflict with holding the company accountable — it is the same goal. A community that loses its mill to disaster loses those 300 jobs along with everything else. The
time to act is before a tragedy, not after.
The nearly 2,000 odor complaints filed by Port Townsend residents between 2016 and 2021 are not the complaints of people being overly sensitive. They are the documented record of a community
being repeatedly exposed to toxic sulfur compounds at harmful levels. The rotten egg and rotten cabbage smells our neighbors have reported for years are hydrogen sulfide, methyl mercaptan,
dimethyl sulfide, and dimethyl disulfide — the same family of chemicals produced by the kraft pulping process that uses white liquor. A 2024 federal investigation by the Agency for
Toxic Substances and Disease Registry confirmed that these compounds were being measured near PTPC at concentrations above EPA's chronic health reference level — meaning long-term exposure
poses a documented health risk to our community. Eye irritation, throat and respiratory inflammation, fatigue, nausea, headache, and dizziness are all established health effects at
the exposure levels being recorded here. This is not a future risk. This is harm that is already occurring, already documented by federal scientists, and already being borne by the
people of Jefferson County. A Longview-scale release of the same chemicals in liquid form — hundreds of thousands of gallons at once rather than through a stack — would be catastrophic
by any measure.
We do not know how large PTPC’s white liquor storage tanks are. We do not know when they were last inspected. White liquor is not covered by the EPA’s Risk Management Program, so there
is no public safety plan on file. What we do know — drawn entirely from official EPA ECHO enforcement data — raises serious questions about this mill’s safety and maintenance culture:
PTPC has been in High Priority Violation of the Clean Air Act for all 12 of the last 12 quarters — a perfect record of noncompliance — with 23 informal enforcement actions and only $63,750
in penalties over five years.
The mill has had 13 or more documented industrial spills into Port Townsend Bay since 2013, with Clean Water Act violations recorded every quarter for three years running.
A June 2025 hazardous waste inspection found specific failures in preparedness, prevention, and emergency procedures — exactly the category most relevant to a white liquor tank failure.
In April and May 2026 — this month — the state issued two new formal administrative orders for Clean Water Act violations.
Total penalties across all environmental statutes over five years: $99,750. For an industrial operation of this scale, that is not deterrence. It is a cost of doing business.
For context: the Nippon Dynawave mill in Longview had a similar pattern of citations and unresolved enforcement actions before workers died. PTPC’s daily production output actually exceeds
Nippon Dynawave’s, suggesting comparable volumes of white liquor in use and storage.
I am respectfully requesting that the Board of Commissioners take the following actions:
1. Formally request that the Washington Department of Ecology conduct an immediate, independent inspection of PTPC’s white liquor storage infrastructure — including tank age, condition,
secondary containment capacity, and last inspection dates.
2. Direct Jefferson County Emergency Management to meet with PTPC and review and update the community emergency response plan specifically for a white liquor or caustic chemical release
near Port Townsend Bay.
3. Publicly request that PTPC voluntarily disclose its white liquor tank capacities and most recent inspection records.
4. Write to EPA Region 10 and the U.S. Chemical Safety Board urging that any regulatory findings from the Longview investigation be applied immediately to PTPC and all other kraft mills
in Washington State.
The full EPA enforcement record is publicly available at: https://echo.epa.gov/detailed-facility-report?fid=110000490326 <https://echo.epa.gov/detailed-facility-report?fid=110000490326>
Our community deserves answers while there is still time to ask them. The window to act — while this disaster is fresh, while regulators are paying attention, and before something similar
happens here — is now.
I have attached a five-page community report compiled from official EPA enforcement data documenting PTPC’s full compliance history. I am available to present this information to the
Board in person at your next meeting on Monday, June 2nd.
Respectfully,
David Ginsberg
Port Townsend, WA
415-342-7445
davidbginsberg@gmail.com <mailto:davidbginsberg@gmail.com>
NOTE TO PRESS: The attached report is sourced entirely from public EPA ECHO enforcement records (FRS ID: 110000490326), the EPA Toxics Release Inventory, and the ATSDR Health Consultation
on Port Townsend Paper Corporation. All data is independently verifiable at echo.epa.gov <http://echo.epa.gov> . I am available for comment or follow-up at the contact information above.
悄ᦍ돤蜡摔·懮�癗낈闇踵㣓鲅ꌤ嗍堯䧚燆ᗩƒ髊ҁ鈐嶔쨄ࢪջ框笧㋛�⋨蛁꽗뀈㈵쥸麻ꅨ鏚姷ꢖ䦠朖뺅즌䣈뿡܄및⭅�㞾潳躓弇ꓜᓦ怿쬯ḟ䋝ꛁ꧍笭➒祗姂罰䃛횯릱��齚⟙⠼쒽Ⓙ퓾ϋႣ家硶ᐟ셿촼ૄ㫯鵾울횲ᗋ飡敒洟�⼾ເ쾏ǥ놔ꘕ낣擃饶Ƌ顶괱鮓ṽ곁沈瀶㹳梯类鍦횢⡻날籫卑節ಶ炰䖊阂녰弉紲謁쓊䳄領ꟗ咚従粬⛸ꍐ�鵹簦㝩ꅅ싑蹷鍲䋎舲蔇䘞毿ꅃ䫎﹝ʮ慸묺쭇炸攔杼氯鐺緤톎윣寭㙤벝퓼
㾹믜죏榌採풶��ȁ톉胣嫝ꙁ稢᭔죫쉣ᆖ暢떩췜ዯ妶蹾ᒟ慏닚稭㳘煱ꆣ䳍䛢셕❨䓠洠죵颬䠉ස䶰総蕿閙⽸璦輚䯗퐵銤㝟듴們掷问킊✣퍭謵锎蔚뵫蜰齫慻춖颓鮄⛏늏즹䵓딟䀼珷砄Յ远㺧୬ड़㺐醾᷎㛌蝩巧淞䏾濂齝弋很亀⏪봉昍뀨է鬂櫝⒑啑힗钫犤�쀰繱㬤靕凞㚪⊋玽�独맹㽦鴒즧ଢ漏ꨃ矪�␎撚ⱄ㚎轒贁濌�㗸끍ᐁ旱믜彇�︲際铏㟤⤍㟟ꓞ쉯װ㻃軳빗ዹ핤ꈉ㓪혤让⺍홫ӛ멨ꮼ㔿剴傒靈刓刹剁텵⧬쯾鼫
瘫㘒큘勞푺䩌깛䲞ﯾ粕䲩칽ꛦꦢ쇫⾗Ԡ컉럖籷ノ矏⑿שׂ嬟孶節䄧욗塭峖씎똞㲓暛떯됯�묹ㄎ灈䞂ꄀࢎ䪴亟〝䲠外䦶ᄒᄄ螐ᙙ참쳚켼萰ē�쥀燆덢饄₁쎏暶湤俦ⲓᇄ趩衦⮨�創⭁᠁욝⏯㌅똯뷩坌�厦ᙦ郕�놨᭗멣⻨ໃ킋䋴괖缴㱳첻绖᯳妄髻因㰓�㒊ꙅ祵ﭰ⼠༷풽⼿Ⳍ쟍ᾥ蚧쭠ꖅ蕙茤杈캖믅龒G蟱魓㨩䵍㝢䲃㚰阩謴�騩謄ꨈ⁘婕댹끙㋊낏㤛馱⦱鱊嶗⼼敛垑㐙ᑚ츅㈬❡汅蘲뉿⽘폠Ǥۤ胡⧲捗㆝甈텺�鏜晞闞
㗕韰諾黂圷曫꽪杈畴蔓꒛䶱Ⲫ좫䨪翴磱ホ♴欹髦싔ᑧ摟拖侶䜣跟慿䔵奈㦠렾㭋탪睪箐蒬횓귢䛬镱௵ᮉ잎쒊褢関頡䃅ヷ웋�뢱䓎㍱뎇㙭턅Ῠ讷啎⬝欨铬訫㊔Ặퟧ滨�鹿菉鉌庚뮈ꡞ埫⤩线艵ൂ픏ꅬ뢢鍚䴞軩䔜�ⳝꋝ㣧ᗢ횘篔퐕㏳胉掁꽯굌㌍�매릒⪇㶑커ꍡ螭❖⭛蒚瀣꼝⚤᧡�툀㯋悙顄悳叡ó츇뜣ᕣ蝴剙듬㲯骚�꿱鶴ꩃ�䑦셦砧ꏩꪤⅎ䉢䏬뱃꼆ƍ돗䖗曜漸㻟缸簳ʲ曲ߐ㪚첕腮㇟穑ᔵ㍯䲙䛩紷ೌ垦톍녖孤襭旯뢯�䀫
龶ὐ뼇垐㧝㽇ꔐ倿괇䄶⁌楔떤༪뽾겤턛↑気涴剓泎覦驒씢㻸莶戼髷覣㡸脲♗ﱩ쑇⧢港銧᙮웅ﻓ驯뵱瘯颥룭ղN擄⦘봳㊋勑쏍겲沇샋ę끄콪ኸᚸ脠燰⦔⚟䜵䟦鹢朝Ἶ顸蟲ᶬ㭲㨩粉貧捵⍑�幌꩕ඓ池궆倵牭ヨ崽촬诫ງ뼿ᯀ樸띏돟못華蘳膺釱ត�⧋귈孯틖挺냒馒襥嚌⹊ꈖ瘬쮁⢨掀Tᣋ㰉㩣䑪삋깡孇ב禭ⷱ厵캧�孰㖪䗹잳늍螘Ⱪ耂ʄꋪ檢㺦⢐渆෨ᡌ溳ే닙벱앴蝒牧莪곯㌹ﺃᮙ캗릜⍴コ鑋廓쯵
嫍抈⾗앖帮䢺놓墱륌兴ࢹܞ�㿞秺昸쪌왻㿹露⒃텝館�䳨檏齺쇿ῇᄒᾜ繼�㹣丬訤퀏㿍◣鋱멬ꪗ蔨枯◣焥餲鍮奄뤂﮳앳튉ﵒ籤뺁骗띍꓿ἧ箠䇌ᓘ凃磱ᗉ쀸悇躧��㏠놥�끻㢸쉁鏩㱒糬罁ꏭ煄ᾢ䘼zĪ郇蜺抖妍⒆膔槺嚁满겁蘮揌휰藏姺㳤鏑ᰇ鷏호蜌Ω讱鄧第슢⤑Ꮵ句뭶햌墸躳嵍�ᘺ뿇밾湦偙᮵뉛쁤퓐䱖ఆ럅眧嘶馮ꑞ뒵�䣰ᚸ夑ᓑ숭䱚䐼츻騤년夈塜₲萋搅䲑授〤㛅謁씈翎㹼穙踈垽ᕚ볟ﳳ捹창얍쟵呝瑔崽极㢜鰣栣
シ僼隝꧋귀놇薄㿔ᗩƝ퓩ᗀ凹ꨶ쫗ﶝ䎦৬ꒃ똰쯶쳈ף齄磔炿恊肭꽾陠㰾铊枕皩ﬔ耳崏腽荡輷⥓揆쪝틥碄沺謹㪨䱇❂뒒徤ᑳɻ䟱؊孬㍜雴㭽⯫㝧鶌窵㍴鹹篷缲ꈷㄸ榌竿臿荣ꧢ魻赧�ꭈ귖㼷魧臘幺뉮빖눾䈳枦쨮㬃搃澃辗믔묗ۉ⻗㔳뀊㕧ꨚ㪱曂㾫鰌䗺ᒝ엃훓뒄ꂚ梐㽖陒䐘劘嵣陾㫞幅딏缇흻䞂ꥯ웥䶽럅湮뾼撩㬍矰�㪟ꊳ䯯妞捱듐꿽沷瞿Ϫ�㾫ಇᖱ�梅嚺�릋伜⤎쇈᫁Ⴉ�ⷜ耜इ痷磗㠼礇│nj筍궱
ڠ囥﹡ㅁ�ꪤḡdz럞ሡ쐙쩢됒嵑덾ꗣ煴첹㋲䟃龘棝咲檮燛쏛䅵碵祼쵔ꉱ댜㙯�㟐瀺碢難䋚漩득⊱㭞摢끁込㐷癰垥윋㍔쉯磀㮡몷살댉䴑늵㨥댏壚므쥔鍅듩ᤅ�ⱙⵦ雵ᛃ枒ᛁ챴羊앢塷師애갣켸궊茼䃁큔㠲㎉鎵㐗扑᪸ર縁ګ䌌쬁膨䍐စ袇麙笳繑⭤醠翟䤌⧿菉貹篴ದ齞䷼ᖪ泯湣놽棱閪釤중㟓ꉯ䀧뛇캛ฑﻹﴸᾜ瘸稢纜ย묜炵튼ᩴ喎㴯ܾῧ鴵滻㿊ᴶꐃ䉍킿ⴖ袙辷妵典帖섗馭煸긦ꕜˠꌅ░꒸㲼䵵ꀚ歺�
�⽺귣ꨅ孟鵫嶒鎐눳Р쮂檪ꮉïፍ絃頋統ﻒ髢杸楩꺍줵勒ﱻ劽쨌嚞㢞�⨆爐즼䁘ნ宅褕멒膭뀱狺ﴞ쐚礼첌禀雀䶗坮硙쒲⼔ﻟ苸ﳟ翩ﯙꨶ瞹צּ轮礗죓ⶲ鈯孥髱닅㗣㭠㙶좓沶焫嬬愸夫鉌떖劔楊⅋ɀ甡䫙紫䨅퇡䞖힗꾅�彂퇻㬒맿晷㤤븄纾ﯽ틆㮙眹쳮婕ᆳ←歰㥴ᷞ蒷蕻䭇ﵽ埣㨼楕픶㧰욼吴㨐䭸雇ﮫ댫㷦럫몝쐳驻버캂ỗ㕚눵붵鋊㗦㞻樺꼷ᰑ䮻廭�汾핛涕罋燙ꄮᦨ꺿媷㪭ꮃퟆ郘멝⪾䕧䇋伒ワ遝鎄
㋱뻳ꎭ댕氕劺嵼㨞ꀤęԹ漴㍃퐶蒟⳺효檀⡕톀仵춴��ꢝ觐ಜ讋蕜�碽姆콤僈�㘦귗僐䋷邞礖兞࿒훂䳥䀞솄�씤ᘌ敊醌廈꼥⡨階�ﳱܕ춙彻뙅ᴯ�赙i叾씊浏瓛橤셫厹ᇬ㮎牵ϛ䴷管��럶먦俬�뺏ꕰ檵潭궵㌮杰쪰趪頨鍓⭓ὧ儧법�恟⎐㤈尙宍櫓ڽ깣ꝅ頷ۍ蹃쓑䴛ꙭ⚽摜㖪㓡㈓錙ᘬ犬ꓧ暱ᘓ谌琑昐衧舢↶j딼顐⢁壎�䳁㋲牻傌幀㞕앁울蚓箤甾㮫ὒᙸ鳕唪�鷍龃榟ᠴ녏囫姭뼽ᄋ枦콆壽�蛾眝祎责죧텾阐
ᔵ흀弉媰䪏튜븲겴뒬㆔鈚䲓跤댰㞅晛꠬苍Ⲋ⦐謣쳙狘珺珦칰헊䖫豮둡ꌅ⌎보겲巚鎒林鏥놓淆⚵끙钻餱ፗ㰛ﷳϯ쀋⫪즨뱹ፄ⥀뱢ᕀ멄ᶨ笢䋝�벼ⴜ䝲븲▤즲겱ﬕ䧾㦣禯熤⯺捻獬徎觵බ໗嗕屗짷鬍ṯ㖭亚笽棒毉夙ﴻ椀껊顫텚忬떝ꎌ원蔝륓㐜䷳껗粽ꙥ賘큨势⦖䀖슃㖾땻槗볱琒飃ṃ툴Ⳬ䍦憿胔植鲢ٜ鳣脜ꨧ㑦Ȱ疖촨♤䑺⇝蒊渤檈䀳ួꏑ덴ꏌ쐁씪譻㝠Ụ땑뙃ꪮ擪鋜䊨�䂺ᒅ䥎ᣴォ䭫ኢ撱濼蘙丽ṷ᤹亝る⡖ⲕ둨䚼ⶣ
圁↠遡�檕歖꜇뽓ٸ폾֠眞⊞䕋瑱蠀⇛社潪βﳿ쿬៳煿韶薊篟㣼륷㊁뺋甽럘ꭎ푥㔪嘝嚫䊧Ꚛ싑噤冋ꌎ짥穰劬䪲춖ᓡꜼ刨儜瓠붲ꚟ䕀⩓謰丘制즘鰍⚡ꤪ쒠裏㌒蕹鞀퀜뽽惀蠝∨觙酀俅ﻞ娜�泭㈯㮝很ⱛⱑ먬꯱�뷴鷩뷴瓩㎲뺡鑢豟譒网㨁辜列念僸䏋瘥憔橇娻覗㏒金됴ഫ䴝텓咮॔茹婪䡵ễꉔ╙⠊䫑氎䁒걇效㖜ꭢ哑⩦븫ᒮ壍嬎ꥰ⼓칧ꠘ녜ษ峥؍厝ⳡ䬦攬튞⭙據噅鮗餷墏飐洅蜚掛㎉ዷ糣ꒋ̠ᔃ鵯両ꚝᖎ뎞␃銜ੀ韺홾
䄬已䟹꺖닭侷㡶�劧邬㟳ﶲ焑헿㽫᧻멪混榛웾蟫㿚�龁誥閞웶鷰罛죹ꬣЍ쿼躼큇瞑㣾漟ﲝ觎홏봬深忥췾斓흳繿黫꽇穬茶厥弃壾⥇䑹籓窪宆ㅌ燳뛟˙錴㡾辧♃㓤採⏒ậ瓩몙㩣䢶璋䳚⡃⤹應秡䌋ꛜݥ馱㱇䫯찑悠볉줶첢ᦳᥕ갶ƣ∑豁ͳ따㞭⥟ꖠ䤃僑淲欜躁嶏奞㻔뤔⁂뇿缟ꥱ�ퟛ罚ꎍ卾컁苚㮤푎�殻퇰牮衿⧮ᮯ뇹ꇺ糦㑸ᨌ닖媇⇖뭟奨쥞抲晝ᱧ踊⡗皸ꨅꬁ烲㠻懌툕锨؊ಱ閧ᾣ煹廙텻㿶닄
樮幘黄컸쇒䧰㏘譗엌聟몧ﴆ�민肸ξ橳媴턲퓹織⩝蕊鰤췡ῼ陸䭏㲅楚뗣逆贅呁化輱⅔찦メꪬ华挪펞嫔䥻兒꺚歸坺꩒ꟾꆏ육沚녻붂ꝋ廉嫑㥔읓틥ﴵ먱龦᎘炾헩嚇얳ꢵ甿ᔴꖧ榠ჾ랏冘ᦝ텭㚢㨭䆪㗻裨鱚貾蜌麻돝룵뺨㺶콘㏖덮묛距悌䊮빕⒚䫛잕낭㍲㙬腇醉弲ឯܪ递䘢꜕쬉㈓䖊岢隩ᑵୋ姸햎攽鮅똶摦햖㯹㥗ᱹ肼極铺꼻睟軍췪㼷ꀕוֹ껨ﲶ區쟳ᨚ�쨊왻ꞧ뒗뀗솺欛㸧瘷忛๏融䆾륾谁旸ᮅ凢쾟햭瑨ᕪ芣
ꒈᡢ切ࣲ鄪焒䬬㘞㫅䊗咥鐫∌⦺ꥎ眈⌒煉米擾큷倕茺츧㵼✵鹪绎붚ᣣ⽒瞽䒌苼纥슺셙�志虗珺쿼쯮淆⢩䐋귧槩䕌떹밟䓬㈹岦ꊽ⡈쿌،媇ꯋ喑犸か塥婵入송卢堳�囯鍐蠂ⵠ̦匔ꔺꀙ脩誑䋷⊿鐻�ᐫ䈉岚홏圣�撊孛쓝틒皲︾钃埵�ﺿ僐윝敾僧퓃웖枤죟�淢ꙙ⯬땝뢶堣獟봄ﻸ荻鱟뙫輷⚶壧饬㚫ퟘ�籂㻮ᶘˮ춋ꩥ袘═ꦚꍄඈ擕斏맣⎬硙ᙝ䯊⥆⣉ꤵठ핇ꀨ뵆푪䚢諪륣뜨憞薅ᔵ᧵䅮펭狥ℎ䃅ዯ뱸緒ᨍ悛粺铁∃芤ء�囏ꍗ
箸擅쇲콒톁헎粥淍㷃뜇得짶꺗秞磧ꆚ鼛抽䎵犫뭹ᮮ춮�墮ꆸ밵ꮣ솹馲뛚᷎㞝⾩ᄼ隆꿗�閖垲㳬寒퐷쾏ﺩ쯏鹏╣䇓뙶뼦쯐焕豓䦊蹡훺貚嫉澘猧嗧礨劅傡䉾턫뀮ᕶ歖掀Ȉ誖殇ؘㆂ嶋鍪魑⧌剓߀욜㺏⇆ꅆ鹾뒤㏚㎒析੨ܺ瞡퉘喗▪膾펵씨늖邕썧괜맨▚埳ᗿﲟ䕮劙ᴸ隟望樠婙ꛠ⌖闈奟鱒喑껢堬⇺鋃䛥㊀鞲ா鱦蹫债㇐샧ꗗ댡㧰먫竆ᖣ굛사ꂨ區䫪শ䄶큰골棵㗪썘묤⹜춍㶥ᾍ⤹₸쭠飚袛�⽙黱ሟ蚷�얓䱜ᾙ㇋
㢀됙Ꮃ�꿛ḹ屘ꭽ샿흦讕ᅦ檸块掩䛥忷ꎏ쮤㛷㍙盪鲶첦ͽ߽隷卲촅樻蟃ⱊ웎䲊맕孪礜薵쐩幧ﹹ�롷䰃댑ퟏ썄梹⹓쥪﵅⣙ꬵଯ䯯蝇킓ଡ㎚�忰碏┡昅䕕⋦呜扔᠓妭떋ᅌ功┄쌯≦୷泳鴊罄잭ꅣ滓圩竵⻎甏宱␏솄剄쩕웊﵏眠玕샸옗轂�篸贷橾ꕤㇾ�춪瞫簽獅蛉뻝ꦆᴝ죙�솑蛪丫澄屙嗘斾㫿�歙뻯隣�쯾ਊޚ腗盉겁ɟ⬙잳닗ᔽꞵ䠢ꈂ莚鰚য華᪐犏ヨ暋㑙⋌₥옾겜듏豂㏐麼㱡竺혽尛굺엕쒀㮥ι쮆䔈炒鲕�䱁ꣀ촁総烽靇篞쥸踯뜾횿믕㜬
窵ꏯ鿓뙗�쵴ꦩ붶৴ꀱ㣠ꁐ뙣䫹⇀죩맮ᵦ욤�⁷菌窠醄ꗒ⃑அ딓뫔屐⼭閦��緥�鰟纛鶗巈棬讹⯰퓜䬽�璳蒟滏䟀턃颿棑ସ쑘⪲ʝ❆�㔪劯즫풦蕘અ풹캀ꔉ暊ἀආ蝅僸蚊�뗎�ᚰ︮瞅ዙ闶澥돞蚤ᆱ도⧟ꃴ茰탘䍬㙕儲ۛ뗓됔蝕듆윤흋ㆢ�"⠕⼿㬯䤷么ᑶ驀⇠揟꘠ᛥ୦ࡦ쥰⸅뺰魴퐁셜냆騺凐ᝬᮿ뱟릡띜짳蔫뜉䷊盕䯃`㺋롹戔鳯峸톨냸헞�댺䵰菓⽷尼璸�ퟑ皷菟溻覙뺲훙似啇콍㺅苀蜬哳歼䚰⎫韙䞖
裚픖箐좃�ᒀ嘆᱔ꃧ㭎Ȍἒ劶屫斘㨕焭迌猬柌殈ﲖ샲⪅촣ꕣ뉶ꏑ餣ᧈ蝏伖ᚄ姞觘眻욞엚猿䭓⊛耯쬫絸⳩鑁氨䘪谪딤襥黂玐ᑄ蠟橅飨빊䀢뻩଼펒뱨陚닗堼隅摅ꓖ᧣蝆ꑵ譖塀달ꃂ捦遼ꂘᕥ␟ꤿ䳶㭌紑ḅ仨֪ⓥṹ晷撞摹蓊⩔蒽켣౻᧐誔ϲ傦韷筞믴ꞧ鷱奿�෨로⎔쇒Ȏਝ镦䌯�蓛Ƌ䒿ꙣ㥜䧉籦䋦⎇⸚龰ⷵ�硙鰉퓧輹㗤꼔착糯᰷퇡Ṯ㏨衉䩏諲뀿議ᴎꇖᵙ痢㩹킬鮡ࠍ抒�쨕誽ᓫ斝ᕚꭈ齀僦䎔ᱽ쳢Ԧ넇㙽ꔅꋈ쟬ᢳᷣ䇴㓱趲ᢈ
섪딌膤⮩㉎처䵪꼊ģ铳Ś휜ᲈ咗贮췄金ꓮ痈﵉␐瀃뙞禲쬱ሼ쇈蠺鈘卓볓㡁鿇⹕駜◼冪鰢슴ẁ⯿㓜흻憹䰐諪셁먶뼊笥隩풍퐠ᮯృ斚聐뉁↭賭냶㜖첒劧鲅鐪Ṃ䅨ꛠᢽᣱଣ⊚㝯戣颈떕㖯蕦喘填蟍慚ᒭ⽊譠ﶜ讈쭐すꝠ䠜符稑䭣�䞩㧞仦悝麷Ά百餫缿酖帊蔴愩�뱕⭯孆皋ᴕ戭庡ԁ퍬䎶똶蛗爄䰰瘟퇒輰Ḗᦧ滑ꨭ뛕煫謺ᑫꕘ孲還۳㘧▓嬋亮䭯꾍尌ﺸᖞ롫맄뉀銴Ꜩ雪揽딽眶小�鯻꿉帞붙퇵�꼧७裏
躒�᭫㟄宦淶셝殞桤䏻屷�绛퓠䷄鷯Ԛ觪辌貂邍氛嗶励✰䣟뾂匱뉯䠚怂硤㌣繃탉潘䛄䮓랯谚礉枖फ䢉�ꃦ歩镅ڔ탸䌗ඟ궔�輷봬涽唁뮟滿쭧�릷誩篍멛㸿띚蟔䷗꾍ⱨ訰몲쪏鬪쥙⪻䝐澦⮩껐됲ଯ총ⵄꢵᚺ孄ꁖྲྀ쓚쎢琖譐Ḡ䀄ୁ瘭Î끑淚ᠴȔꆹ�䋕竈ᖃ憛鲆쭯䯋착氯�졔�汳솼鱦ꂳᙝ춴횂遙ࠥ벛霕�欺馆䃉䞅⺔䆽ꗩ凑娲㮺䴁ꒊ勞ꐞ厲販綯啗퀗ﱭ쪫ᝄ泘椢髻딭涮ᮥ枛趼岷䤦줼寝歠巈窻휤ꚹⴤ㭁θ띝餝댫ⱻ툇쪚岄ř燎ᛉ
䌾졽陒�⮱鍔エꒌ꼝皂스弪鳽裵댕繤슓⤳⧉蘚ऱ䳦馔떩펫ᩬ䚛탣磪亭퇧䏖鲆꓂銹鎒ꑙ歖ㄝ⓰⛣Չᑄ덢䠅즚䖱ܘ癌쐜䧤ꔁ纮雭誌⸍讼伍쯽�ս律⭀笿쓿ꗞ假啵襫쥥䷌㬝駰겇穜Ꭰ蹵뚌銵⺷䙡ڰꪴ練澚ꖺ섚버᪠ꎠᶀ쾨戾퇇㐴誝헦ࣨઋ啌ᚦ欓뎂ꘖ뭈䡜�싦옮癩Ꝣ粳䶥질犡祴힔瞗뎕뗥ཤ卌ꪘ汲岶햗岅蕖読Ὄ浲祖ヺ⸠휓寒쐫ᛄޏ靀揈ꐟו詓ᓸⴢ閇はⴐ᎒❯ᛌ箥쨼�寪�쫠�ꆵ毚昖禯ꉤ勒㞳蒵ᐶ깦ᰏ哜
쏠⾃课떂汕첨睌쪭꾷鎙굜ᵣ螝㗽腕㟫⥟땔�짹痉㬝㛫縮⯨�肯ᴆ㎣痨精侥ᆱ㷼乄⯺᯲ᰬ엗惮쌱妚ⵐ䗎쁂찉ᓒ暈牟䈒復Ꞑ蠏㇙ƨ釤ꗁ纟峪槶闶ṳ闶䡻뫜⏹팘䫹닛훨퉖坂톎沑㢱䛌泞ꨶ죍旜솼얈嘭苬㾃鎑憜∳ﱕ썦ᄙ⤍䣠ꝋ씱䙄ﱅͮ낛౺ꝱ杋텛猹쓟쾾콮鰎ꐾ湔㭞露�闇킑竐綶ᕍ⮣�孥䬋뱚꽛샬ሷ๚#˞䱚䜰굟᧕镒ꕈ필⭜憇㬥䏉謆☍鞓吼莨Ԉ㓐两郵⩘㨍蜭ᱍ䞦過ﰝ韪ᩥ㨐繴蹞ᚠ궺䐠潐촒렟ᚷ⽽潼ᣡ悫㘱툹ῐꦹ濷
㢀䋺깊컝騻�䘺䍼鹿怌쾜庛⇏搫奋夙챞⹁㑧衞硫廹㽩띸മ⚲驫ꝗ痡瀺䈐栣愆뤧ꩿꊵ谱墬㓯贛荞㞞෨䎆㐺鮢ಁꜰ楥ꔸ㼾棃걠쿄ヨ쟒庉芲觤軥抵⃞揞錱璧䉑䄖湮쮥⊵ਯꨊ䨝鮺搱䩕ࢲ䯄㪅⇊㏥꾋퀿ጅ乀䣩橛唾ꣿ鈙갛暰ꩥ臑갟䃦妿䛎छ�쪱譚�䠞벼ߝⰋ쳫㿸眗渖滩⩌榛㿀큡�̀ꖞ�彁⫳굆́R삽嘗�ൽ퐪棔㓚殷歎탞궼楑ⵘ逴櫣ၔ뒰銐滅煋順ꮐ᪴妐츮爨轟ृㆎ䳎㾉в緑죣줊꼻综囹렧澵蒿絮◕��緑뾋洀Ẹﮆ촵
⩈垬锫뉞썾ᾁ菐┰㶵킌鄬樕濨帿䇇꺎毖ꐹ赠䙊锲뚕ﴢ䵂₶瓺Ȭ䅯锅ퟸ瞋ⲍⲌﯝ䅹岛腗腚鏿㙋叴䷒ᴥ伸ﻮ폵摻븣ᕲ᧕鵸⎁՛⟖꒡찤ⱇ⪂ㄡᠰ䚰ꚭꝖ륓萴�拢곈昅릾穗柸䁠駤禄ゎ逘檘踄籃鰤軼鶘矝��䨐劫섖ᝳ瓹詯ᔵ籾也楑㷒ꙶ鎺勒둉ᯆ뼕ׂ䋚啢࿌剢婽烄옜萾꾸Ꮲ嗐歂立速桯紐豃ⓦд⪲줫咓腠绸篼뛐鰿媟ぴᎪꄌ瘤目篼㴤畛愰ݻﻎ騻缻麘쒵ﷺ뱐콈ꓯ퍧菱韬诰ꅬ㯢꜔놷麟웕廎會詍
㨅럮靰ㆈ枦뿩ꤺ쭜ᇜ㼫ꀒ䋔ၹ蠽ꀫᓼ铿뼝泌蔺煖ꥄ䙔䥔쾪ﺨ瘝望媛鐯琧먕ᮏ枾黸캱㝤찫妷旸藥⮤纒㲟鯋�ꉓ薩꾩뺧權ಉ왧㊏쮯눒쳞죮現Ⲷ굂ᩰ࿊⧾㯊᷿㻅⬚犅勶咹键륒⹔䮕勥咹键륒﹔◑뷷뉿頸⋒ᮕﲠ礩偝㿉咷ꄪ蚬荥㤴ᓏᑖᕎ咾䝴ﶔ쿅礫헊竫㮦ᷓア뒰佥枹�닪쩛媾헶軲�碨寋㷩抻ꕧ늱镸櫡羙鹿⡫嗯垿芣⪒粕⬨짾�勒嗟蘘懩ൿⲟ꩙ᧁ앴삆톈⏒挂轆鐟陠웩䥗윰▗Ř�값
뉤류ᔟᰳ䟫铍얱값蹡�朔ᷤ遌嵐ቛᢌ%Қ䙣銙섭匬ꊔ悔톎碧堤ॊ㉖铆ॖㅖ뇥푾穌䯲값驡㙓끉蕁麀윑壂곆䤯윰摤䗝ա羭艎﵉फ뉿铞홉ᓋ텖悔r蔶ꓕ鬾悗쾨卖겘妰Ⱂ忲䖄课좰ᅿ烙숯B塅뿤솘䅬䖂课좰ᅿᠶ⥫䶬嶠䂛ົ秪ᚉ퐝ላ稭㞨�섫錜牕蔛傍⺯婹㦂⾆䄹ᠣ鋆䧯蔂榓濽頥ᅯ슄ɼ羅Ḅ邦ҥꕿ⩰ឭᠤ巪鼢꒭土ҝ㽃劮朊ዝ�傷㬸�蓬浱龴ॱﴦꓬṰҠ纓勶颸�섭ﺤ੦榻ꜿ頥䏴ꯥ㪿チӪ풺琉Ꮹ�Ꮻꋤ旲恆頪ꦜ꠆ᦗɣ뷰ঁ
ጱ៰䦘덚踖Â侓퐿椇劋팸賀ᅃ溘ᮨ䲣Ẅ;枭珠뚘䀴荩䆣ඨ댰퍐筅肟㩱᩻ᇺ�搙Ȟቸ藎ㄈ쯬⼘Հꎱ왪煅䏰錏囐熀ヽ衣ⷙ嶵䜇偣칋͎醎䴘྄䩁䈳ⅹ贰㱰月굈犟㥢抍ℿ劉躁ല蝧봨棤宅薞썫暴娚匍ৎ⽐ꏋ瀝�툉⛫漨퉗ϫ䖴�挃丒팏䅏䣂⭮𢡄퐈︐왍ᠤ莧辜ᘂ롁Ȳ桜ⶠ詅⩤ᓼꈧ쌁䑴䩮죝ꗟ겶㙛턪冡쟠ᴸG䐞᧩ム炅遵Ꮢ熊梱⣻⍇ꨱ憫ꉴ7U海䭃쟙謿籽ཐ勢ꉪ゚洋耧䐟⎎艐䴒쩮჻Ꮰ⎤퉴挳䍐ᦸ늡䣙⤵콌꤄柀皜돂꙲ꦖ褁큾
ࠎ폝쮀ꔤꑒ葷ᯢ䋛ⱹꎞᔼၹ즍湕呂ࢻ৷Ŏ�洰⤷�絅Ӄ朝抒席ድ躐듽䧯셊栞ꔕ죧荕༔鹙쨗⨦⅝䩪ϸ⌵ᨱ녜룣籮㮐ᡸ掂꒗쐧씞嵱熱ꐮ鑀Ⳙ폥딐讜泱ꉖ䠴橭媜沏៩黲㍜ꅎ桂둟坌�袻��䭄䰳彵㟖䘯㲁ߺ嫱ꂙ萃鄒⢖伝跶橡猽罔滈᎔揔㿸劔쯼䪴ﲴ利숥߄䩍袞⭠卋蟮⒴璣Ꮪ撒뷢ᛋ鐒Ჸ뺦䠱㡭줪爷ᢔ횡丼钩벹ꭜ呝縲༊穋䇰皏□刔仏골㱣ɐ⏔㆓卶ᖿ加䏵⣐邴秏㺤屷◠⒋跫譻豈㉣V㢕㟴緺㺂萾飬㪂乑횲栄居㾻阪嫉賱湈챣≲
礉⢂兯ȋ壒咣➗뤤⢻懍츩뺈碇㼆뿥木轙뵅钚렼ȸΉ屢袙詩覟ﴋⲀᱢ史䏚챒デ馭�㚈켒ѱ픚◆⦝熔烼㋙踤謭⃨ꋭḄ팍㌨첾糏욐窏⃟亽絮뫦므볉쉪턵⚟ⷒᗣ뛏团輓뉄崌�⌨艀ႆ▿⡊봂⏅袬◅䔠Ⲙ紓⢉轃딈ธ嶲휯뾥ꮝᆉꑞㄲⳒ✸⥦鷼鑲ƣۉӎ〒ꘘ撟㣌癟譁蒡ᇘࣽⱿﹺ䩡ᲁ禖㽱ᣴẢ뗹リ凉츦㤟얒鑹叨徖ꄕ䊾햔䒠엷깣䏿ᨤ冎ꄟ㩚筁괗豈覼ﴑ헯㤀떾촱泴팗䜂ჽ묭䵩퐻벑᮵凁퐓䄶ᎍ咝ﵒิ䆵䶻옴綉썴❧漜㺡薮㤱ཚ㯭⾡
浲댳躙雐득෯勍爻嫅�위渄庥᱐Ꭿኮ୧勭ᑌ窅䘡狡�裩昲ᮨ濺캓䀶㾴㾂뼙슅㆝嬼䰤⠛䢏뗏冀㴇딢⍻倷䖚㭬ഩ瀭ꑞ馥䁢⹆梕�︑䧴衧ࢌᵾ㕔Ṑ冴导�ě퉳⭿ᆥ沮钢僶㗮㱋퐣큶㢣ꉕ횤橒圈༉Þ굿�퍵ᅏ�龮辞毩㺐勗痎⏑ᩑ⽑ᖕ撒䷙룩푰ꩾ춉喴ꔃ➸↦吭䕻旬ᓭ쁊᱄좏ᄶ夗薫낏넑珞⛼퉉ͺꯁ㘧蟲峵旺ꊡ벬ଝᬈፂ擜塀ਛ虏ﻂと儴㐪辌�퇁梱䐎삙ꥰだִ쌆妁殡〲䯑쿰ꚅ슣桸㠴త⚅싧璁ਕ埈䮵
侏ꆉ탐ꡮ鬚�螦搣�悱ᡄ⑧ᘔ茚⇁룿贠洈あႨ䴉螇ስ·烄Ⱐॄ䊽灇〨ऑᒬ脢ႀ㏘᠘พଌ拣キ蠜蔌鎃䂄옺⁰䞎ᭊ䇂࠘턋羰뀸ῇⷞ䚄鰾爻鵥數恷穴�纣䨘�ᰐ蜊蘈녹⾾踐醐䮫쫋뵨걛탟ᬛ늃⦴鿬不ઌ⍝耣먖荃ু㎡㐸ᨖ䟷쉜罆ᰴਜ藺㼞㺥鐢훗쑔ᔆ팢鎓䇣箠㐤ⴑ똕Ꚅ㶅㧾ᩡး밥픦㑂త΅棾◀܌錣翀ᢟ☖䇃㬸䴄迭錈悞ෝ凎쬾賜ূ䨐٘졆⸈䷲ᆥ权ᰲ鸚訞Һ䖢군岋༣萀軍攁頉싍솠ꆉꉡ㉲ꇶꄹ堰䨤ꄵ凰諘䁊᧸䐎�ϣ쮐
絣꒭⠜숌턨Ềၰᵆ촎豎ﲇ쯃夗쨅悄躜艎༒ࠇ꒙壍籠㥲셇⚰ꓦ䓦퀠Ⱨᠸ鰄ോꈆ⍲ჱŕ행愮ῐ封ፃ䔱薗㡐贖홎㱹要�擠㡠蔍㵇죤ⴃ䡷儦檥ℑ醈썮댗ⵉ䠺型鬉蕷⚀髂䳀ᱠ鋬箲閹嘓댮荳⍡丑᪄퀁Ⰽ쀈ꍕ㽡晰◘蒌曁筁욆ꁑ砘ህ쮅킅�Ӫ詡犯夙ﻏ⩶䈈䣾Ф䎖援㐸봴␇២䇝ᱰ匸穈䙜킭㤣垚⢋썆䐩尹鶴ᬰ躌甄䥳䛪鞰轏䄇앏䦱慟헑ࣂ裔蔈愮桏㠸빂鐃錡䃓摐琬㠽豍䈷┪ĭ㴊础$ᮾ⁺隲璸呑荅ↇꍅ㢑配ᶘࣹ褚䰙➇餀㡠ค⮲ᐰᖕ긬ꃇ
쏼橁畸誢㍃蒁Ÿ迾ಘ蟅�層ꑓ酓㼱㕐堘륦Ӿ썂ᑈ覔岸帰탑訿쐁�薚꺞�蛾曮붡𡷘ퟕ퓞ⓜᬸ晴篛뫛퀊뮢뎡護헐㐢湴협瞷뤶ᯍ鮻穻꺄ꅮ썽軆曶殨峯뇛ꦩ뎽桕俾坻༞柽足⃝㋉淶쾌䈌綋�걧拙篬嬢⣂⤥邊䨔�溕뙈�呒裚䬖◶몕齾鈙绷罿ퟜ﷽꽞ㆌ鹳秳珎켾㳧玜柆쳌띁ф≗퐨奰鄔Ꙁ㌉逥賴剀靇䉨늴ꃇ蠍晖餴ꀆᵐ薴줎ꢊ浧䎢孂鍘찬Ӊ硰偽쳑Ҁ䊎┰妘셡셑㐶ہ퀤⍤ጝ﨓㩐ꃖ⓶纺ꈤ醡齄㘀ዪ쵀瑴ࡍ䍋➁枥䎢씴䱵ᒠﴒ新泭
ࢍ⛴㱰콗梊䙮഻猽⬳䠒쁢⒳굙땴鈥᠉ິ䢉䶦ƈ伔些螰崹�賏⒰㚅긟砈贈⚶븓ꋫ큏ı酥鵩ὗ揼䨅ẏ툅ꡢ惝櫋ᾎᤅ勎햟웭�忑櫘㰾帏뼋꼌ツ꼆ꇸ㿟͕闻ᄑ붕闿ᄑ돷䯷�ᥟᦟꗼ謫⯿ヒ謫⯿ヒ騳쫿¦즘㛿뼻零늿뿹零쟿零옩臸ྦྷҵ䍟詿莔䕖殷탇„갞ᄕ퉇퇧韻퓽툏舐㴈㚄݂躡꿀次碍ਜ鲬�㴏偁練ゾ⟰Ϭꄙ宿⇍늀˿뎋叠爆눂若陕忶臾쭞璘ힽ鼄㩂ġᢁ庴衤ؿᡭ䆇뢛چ맾隕岁ⷢꛋ齿鰩븋⻲┍Ɯ蕐ᣓ贓ꇙ끌ᔰ�茋
煂¬⌋ʃᰇ젦Āᥜઑ傌鐄ڪ⊃죲▀妀⋕⁔✒�罂페䍝紐䚳䫛퉨耞⫘ࡡෞ樎ꖹ䢂曦濢ⷹ姐뵘�㲭ªꀙ騢⨀勼ᰞ蔆僁ꃊ㞊燎뗎爗ϴ蕴o⯬䋚䀙슽櫩귂谑頨ᤵʇ榸㌄椊뫫�퀧㐫ဨׇ큰餚䱐༤胷䂠鱷 歄ꉁ뻸ഗ啖灛聢质䜏簉寧ӹ⡸䎒͝톂稖耺㫈�䁆倃꧃ꪩ梫ݬ弐迹왨 籩ᑖ읜ཛྷ̧ⵈ≑突섾㺿肙逦㛍ꮩ⨫ᦫ呬쀴⨁⤸所蓩횄ℼ勲ҝ䊠埅くƔ꜂㥂怡ሻ蕆⅂ᩩᑓ鎶Ꚉ韪匋ᔷ᮪掓赽ᡷ侑㙧䒓짔蒔鎫ፃ漫뼷╛⸇禍玤抶録돶粖쓽腪ࡌ䆼獼㏽鮫凗䘞層
��嵋⇇伈课펖Ⅳ⥜龜ﷹ諘遲㖟軿龫ࡓ膪쵃㔱ᮽ跄臰উ㕪秳㮇⹅ᑗ꾘䨣䭧鮞뽜퍺ꋦ쓳夾徘ᒟﳒ釡⼌京�璧螻熼쌕녨릹㎷�ꎸꋅ㳆徯勩盽䚔䢿阱禶㡒옑웺ᓦ�鉺룠抠䯻�贷槛돟㴆蕋育숳ࠀ厃찪Ԋ㮲휉녣䶃⪙놩፴阒ࡀﰀ뱱⨒鼟ಒ醂�묋ꨗ쨔喛㢫⬁ǚࢢ쁓‘᧦ᇦ䮖鐫缐쁬ꖄԄԨ炙嫐隕嬫钻⹖툪∯鑨쀐醎尙뒗⊀职聭㟑耚渥ṙ㰠簼ƭ䈼菾僤䔀埓䄊섳酥횟鰣╦㮁勇僗㞋ᆝꝘꇵ饓詳睽灜똷어푄ﴀ斠ᬒ둣䝖淦