Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout077DRAFT | Page 1 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC 1 Johnson, Reid and Lianna Brinnon ••• negative impacts of project; Hood Canal; more studies needed • 2 Simmons, Donna Seabeck; Hood Canal Environmental Council •• allow more review time; additional planning commission input; build-out period • 3 Morris, Carol Gig Harbor. From Morris Law, LLP, purpose of public hearing; adopt regulations before agreement; specific comments on regulations • 4 Watson, Jim not stated ••• specific edits on Parks and Rec MOU; water quality monitoring plan too focused on marina 5 Hammons, Dee S.not stated shares link on Atlantic Salmon 6 Sather, Eleanor Brinnon •• refers to items proposed in developers vision statement not part of MPR; rec center will not be gifted; private gain at community expense; health care issues; local wildlife and elk not considered • 7 Cecil, Nick Brinnon ••project badly needed, will enrich local economy 8 Murdoch, Miriam Brinnon ••••••• concerns regarding impacts to aquifer and groundwater, traffic, low paying jobs, wetlands and wildlife impacts, tribal fishing and hunting • Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) Part I: Summary of written comments received February 7, 2018 to April 13, 2018 DRAFT | Page 2 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 9 Murdoch, Miriam Brinnon Duplicate Record #8 10 Lewis, Tim Black Pt. •• MPR will improve area, improve local economy; great project • 11 Culp, Scott Brinnon ••developer has met requirements • 12 Germaine, Cindy and Terry Brinnon •••• too large; water supply concerns; noise, traffic; Hood Canal shellfish issues • 13 Baubin, Dr. Stephen not stated great boat destination; please expand • 14 Nuerenberg, John and Sally Brinnon traffic, density and utility issues are all addressed; • 15 Redmond, Jim and Sandy Brinnon •enthusiastic supporters; important voting issue • 16 Dalgleish, Ken Kingston •frequent visitors; project provides many benefits • 17 Ruthrauff, Cliff not stated Empire State Bldg. completed in one year and 45 days 18 Wuhl, Eric Visalia, CA •• Own Brinnon home on short- term rental; project will be environmentally careful and help community • 19 Boldt, Jim Lilliwaup •• Size appropriate; will provide jobs and local economy • 20 Mann, Garth not stated •Letter of thanks to J. Boldt 21 Baish, Joy Brinnon •• Developer has contributed to local community events; park and rec activities • DRAFT | Page 3 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 22 Baish, Joe Brinnon •••• water supply concerns have been met; reclaimed water good; quality project; good business decision; will help county economy • 23 Mitchell, Robert not stated • EIS data outdated; concerned about ecological, health and safety impacts • 24 Paulsen, Alan not stated • strongly against project; solitude will be destroyed; concern over project going bankrupt • 25 Petrick, Cheryl not stated • project should move forward; issues have been addressed • 26 Ianelli, Jeannie Brinnon • reduced scope is reasonable; project would be a great compliment to the area • 27 Williams, Ted Brinnon • this project has taken too long to complete; resort offers positives to economy • 28 Abercrombie, Deborah Nordland •••••• oppose current plan for development based on issues and concerns of selected topics • 29 Simmons, Donna Seabeck; Hood Canal Environmental Council ••• build out period too long; adoption timing of regs and agreement; enforcement; dramatically change rural character; request extension of comment period • DRAFT | Page 4 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 30 Shaw, Allison Brinnon •••• opposed to project; concerns about water pollution, marine and road traffic, local services • 31 Dolan, Terry and Kathy Bainbridge Island ••• urge approval; good environmental stewardship in marina and good facilities planned in resort; will help local economy • 32 Beathard, Trey and Trish not stated it is time to say yes to this development • 33 Gash, Robert and Kelly Brinnon ••• support project; will help local commerce, services, recreation • 34 Marquardt, Will Brinnon •• healthy economic development for south county; environmental fears overblown • 35 Fischer, Mark and Jane Lilliwaup •• project will benefit property values, tax benefits; jobs, infrastructures and social benefits • 36 Bartlemay, Marvin and Lorra not stated ••• impressed with environmental details; excited about facilities planned, jobs, services and revenue. • 37 Polacek, Ron and Beverly Brinnon strongly support project; great community improvement • 38 MacAliff, Will and Jobe not stated •• marina is best managed and environmentally friendly; resort will do a wonderful job for everybody • DRAFT | Page 5 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 39 Thenstedt, Phil Brinnon •• development will be attractive and environmentally friendly; help property values and local economy • 40 Swanson, Clayton not stated real benefit for South Jefferson County • 41 Peterson, Doug and Kay Brinnon project delay due to non residents of Brinnon; approve project • 42 Lacey, Gordon Brinnon approve project • 43 Knoll, Duane not stated South Jefferson County needs project • 44 Verboort, Ken and Barb Portland, OR • Marina is well managed; resort will make area nicer to visit and stay; everything done respectfully • 45 Moses, Dale Gives history of project; summarizes development agreement; reviews Planning Commission issues • 46 Visser, Andy Brinnon ••••• thirty conditions have been met; read studies; project is sensitive and will help local economy • 47 Talbott, Tim Brinnon •• Project will bring a number of positives to Brinnon • 48 Haugan, Dennis Brinnon • Project is a positive to help address blighted properties • DRAFT | Page 6 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 49 Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated No comments. Submits 2009 study on fiscal and economic impacts of destination resorts in Oregon and a press release about the 2009 study 50 Brinnon Group'Brinnon Requests extension of comment period; supports mandatory review of financial results and business plans for each phase; recommends bonding; cites findings from Forks and Oregon • 51 Baish, Joe Brinnon •discusses local economy issues • 52 Hackman, Jim Port Hadlock •••••• oppose current plan for development based on issues and concerns of selected topics • 53 Hackman, Wilma •••••• oppose current plan for development based on issues and concerns of selected topics • 54 Mann, Garth Brinnon •••••• Reviews history of project; discusses support for development regulations and development agreement • 55 Coleman, Don not stated provides duplicate copy of comment letter #53 56 Holbert, John Brinnon •• looking forward to resort and amenities; put old campground to good use • 57 Moore, Richard and Sheila Brinnon ••extremely important project • DRAFT | Page 7 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 58 Roberts, Larry and Laurel Portland, OR •• will help stagnant economy and draw tourisms and local jobs • 59 Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated no comments; provides copies of two 2016 letters regarding development regulations and developer communication; provides copies of two 2018 comment letters on development agreement and development regulations 60 Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated submits duplicate copy of resort study found at comment #48; includes 2007 comment letter on Comprehensive Plan amendment; and, a 2009 review of water quality and water supply issues 61 Culp, Cecil Brinnon ••••• Cites similarities to Port Ludlow and environmental and economic benefits • 62 Wantoch, Rick not stated •• Current marina user concerned about resort development ruining natural beauty • 63 Woehr, Judith Heckert not stated statement of agreement to comment #61 • 64 Wantoch, Rick not stated •Pleasant Harbor will lose it bucolic, country feel 65 Wilde, Rose not stated •••• Requests project be scaled back to 40 units and no golf course • DRAFT | Page 8 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 66 Farleigh, Scott not stated ••• Support the project with great enthusiasm; responsible to environment and to Native American Community • 67 Marshall, Vistoria Starr Brinnon ••• Urge approval of project; lists environmental, economic, services and infrastructure reasons • 68 Verschueren, Lynne Brinnon ••Project will improve depressed local economy • 69 Hisey, Lynn not stated • help provide good jobs and tourists to businesses; please support • 70 Myhr, Pam not stated ••••discusses mitigations and supports project • 71 Marshall, David Brinnon ••please support project • 72 Frank, Merle not stated •support project; improves economy • 73 Holmgren, George and Patti Tacoma •good for visiting boaters • 74 Cooke, JT not stated • is developer's representative; provided clarification on the development agreement placeholder on wastewater treatment (Appendix I of Agreement) 75 Blair, Barbara Jo Port Townsend •••• wants project put on hold; cites Port Gamble S'Klallam Tribe treaty rights; water quality concerns • DRAFT | Page 9 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 76 Conley, Mike Brinnon •• project will bring needed jobs and more social activities • 77 Lagenbach, Michael Brinnon ••••••• Cites the positive benefits of the project for water supplies, general environment, taxes, jobs and traffic flow • 78 Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated submits 2010 report from Silver Tip Solutions on a "Water Budget Analysis for Black Point Peninsula and the proposed Pleasant Harbor Marina and Golf Course;" and a July 17, 2009 Memo providing a review of the Draft Supplemental EIS water supply and groundwater impact analysis (recommends more testing) 79 Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated submits Brinnon MPR Opposition Group comment letter on FSEIS (Dec. 2015) and July 6, 2016 letter from the Planning Commission to the Board 80 Chambers, Lauri Nordland •••••••form letter in opposition • 81 Neuenschwander, David not stated do not keep comment period open DRAFT | Page 10 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 82 Visser, Andy Brinnon Requests hearing be held in Brinnon so that local Brinnon residents can testify; expresses concern as to who from South County is the 'Brinnon Group' 83 Peterson, Doug and Kay Brinnon Requests hearing be held in Brinnon so that local Brinnon residents can testify 84 Kocks, Joe not stated Support project; reviewed materials/record; please approve • 85 Deschamps, Paul Mason County Planned development at Black Point is in right direction • 86 Dudley, Robin Port Townsend •••Please do not let this project go forward • 87 Graham, Steve Brinnon •• Proposed development provides affordable housing and jobs for workers; balances environmental concerns with economic opportunities; approve the project • 88 Kittredge, Kit and Meyer, Dr. Keith not stated ••• Project will be at the expense of local infrastructure, environment, quality of life. Kettles unique and should be saved. Fire/EMT are maxxed. Few low wage jobs • DRAFT | Page 11 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 89 King, Dr. Richard and Laura Brinnon ••• The pros of this development greatly outweigh the cons; environment fully protected; support project • 90 Unruh, Doris not stated •Support project • 91 Durgan, Craig Port Ludlow • approve project; will help jobs, economic development and tax base • 92 Burns, Robert not stated • support project; good thing for county and people • 93 DeBeau, Terry Port Hadlock ••• Project will impact traffic. Kettles are unique and sacred. Project will cause water pollution • 94 Hammons, Lois J.Port Ludlow •• project is carefully and intelligently planned; is a win- win for County • 95 Graham, Belinda Brinnon •• This project will help address housing crisis; offers short term rentals and offers jobs; development can be accomplished while respecting the environment; approve project • 96 Ross, Rebekah and Beattie, John Hal Hood Canal adjacent to property •••• Has substantial issues with water supply impacts and contingency plans lacking; impacts to wildlife of float planes; long term monitoring needed • DRAFT | Page 12 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 97 Swanson, Clayton not stated Time to finally approve • 98 Wexman, Todd not stated ••• Ten page comment letter from the Brinnon Group that may be from the past as there is no specific comments on development regulations or development agreement; comments refer to Board "findings and is critical of implementing ordinance and of 18-hole golf course • 99 Davis, Christina Phillipsburg, MT • Owns property Brinnon; asks for project to be supported • 100 Hogenson, Scott Port Ludlow •• Supports project; asks Board to rely on data and studies rather than emotion regarding impacts; project will improve tax base, services • 101 Grau, Diane Brinnon ••• against project; will impact canal and fishing; traffic accidents will increase • 102 Sickel, Karen Brinnon ••• Objects to out of county residents criticisms of projects; concerns and impacts have been addressed; supports project • 103 Coleman, Don Brinnon Requests if hearing can be held in community of Brinnon DRAFT | Page 13 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 104 Siefert, Peter Brinnon ••• Provides comments on the Draft EIS concerning golf course fertilizers; water supply salinization, etc. • 105 Crenshaw, Roger MD San Diego Support project; hopes it moves to permitting stage • 106 Crenshaw, Susan San Diego Support project; it is "green"• 107 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Duckabush River ••• 35 year residents; project will not improve environment or economy • 108 Peterson, Jean M (Wasell)Bremerton • Strong support; will help Brinnon; project has address environmental aspects with due diligence • 109 Justin, Jones not stated •••Supports project; allow it to go to permitting stage • 110 Murdoch, Miriam Brinnon Cites state office guidance paper; cites Planning Commission statement that mitigation not possible • 111 Robinson, J not stated supports project; wants it approved and moved to the permitting stage • 112 Foszcz, Roger Port Angeles •••• Opposes project for traffic, services, environmental and tribal treaty reasons • 113 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •••• DO not delay project any longer; local economy, services and local ecology will improve • DRAFT | Page 14 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 114 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow Cites examples of success from Port Ludlow MPR; lists all the work done analyzing issues; stop using staff time and county resources; project ready to be approved • 115 Helander, Marge Port Ludlow supports project wants it to move to permitting stage • 116 King, Marlene Mill Creek • supports project; will be a beautiful addition to community • 117 MacAliff, Will and Jobe not stated wonderful place; needs more handicapped spaces • 118 Langenbach, Michael Brinnon •••••• supports project; good water treatment; one kettle preserved; good for tax base, jobs; all items have been addressed • 119 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Developer has been patient and has done all that is required; project will benefit all citizens • 120 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• project can reverse years of economic hardship; environmentally sound project • 121 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow Duplicate of Record # 114 122 Jones, Juliet not stated Supports project; wishes it to move to permitting stage • 123 McKay, John Brinnon • Government is strangling development. Lossen the stranglehold • DRAFT | Page 15 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 124 Visser, Andy and Jolene Brinnon ••• Please approve project. Jobs, tax base, sharing community assets now and in future.• 125 Schindler, Valerie Brinnon •• Supports project; wishes it to move to permitting stage; will bring a bright future • 126 Kleyer, Gerald Brinnon •• Project will bring much needed employment, community pride, investment, truly what community needs • 127 Schryver, Elysah Quilcene Supports project; wishes it to move to permitting stage • 128 Snyder, Angelina and Ben Brinnon •• Project will help existing and future families in Brinnon; approve project • 129 Dillon, Jessica Port Hadlock •••••Oppose current plan • 130 Burden, Lys Port Townsend •• Preserve the kettles; discusses geologic and tribal significance • 131 Reed, Sandra Brinnon • please support project; will bring jobs; share local beauty • 132 Oslake, Morgan Brinnon Writing to register opposition to MPR • 133 Caddey, Patricia and James Port Ludlow •Project will bring jobs • 134 Devine, Lori and Patrick South County ••Project will bring jobs and revive a dying community • 135 Wexman, Todd not stated MPRs are gated and off limits. We feel findings are questionable; see our groups critique and brace yourselves for a lawsuit. • DRAFT | Page 16 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 136 Y M not stated • Traffic will be awful. Keep private lands private or preserved • 137 Coleman, Don Brinnon •••••• Describes history or project; of EIS work; of tribal and other consultations. Project is environmentally and economically sound • 138 Lowe, Cheryl Marine Res. Committee Port Hadlock •••• Review and comments on Development Agreement Appendices with respect to stormwater, monitoring, groundwater, wastewater; supports Planning Commission letter; requests data and a contingency plan • 139 Johnson, Reid Brinnon ••• These comments supersede ones previously submitted. Objects to size, golf course chemicals, EIS. No independent studies. Oppose project • 140 Nelson, Debbie not stated ••• Project is vital, community needs this to keep town alive. • 141 Mitchell, Andrea not stated •• Describes personal history of involvement and impressions of the project; believes impacts and benefits are glossed over; opposes project • DRAFT | Page 17 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 142 Mendes, Maria Kala Point •••• Opposes project; will impact rural character, environment, water quality and destroy kettles; monitoring inadequate; traffic study inadequate; not reasonable size • 143 Ellers, Debra Port Townsend •••••• Oppose project; describes impacts to environment, economy, traffic and other concerns • 144 Perry, Gail not stated •••• Oppose project; describes impacts to environment, economy, traffic and other concerns • 145 Marx, Janet Port Angeles •••••• Oppose project; describes impacts to environment, economy, traffic and other concerns • 146 Mitchell, Robert Brinnon •••••Critical of project history; impacts not addressed • 147 Skinner, Gil and Barb Port Ludlow • Supports letter from Wm Zinheim. Supports project and economic benefits • 148 Adkins, Jonathan Olympia •••• Supports project; marina well managed; projects impacts addressed; good for area • 149 Brotherton, Tom Quilcene •••• Project has been exhaustively studied; impacts eliminated; ignore opponents; urge approval • DRAFT | Page 18 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 150 Koan, Cynthia not stated Planning Commission ••••• Chair and Vice Chair of Planning Commission cite concerns previously communicated in 2016: impacts still exist; development agreement needs revisions; kettles need to be avoided; project size needs reductions • 151 Huxtable, Marion and Ryan not stated •protect kettles from destruction • 152 Perry, Stephen not stated ••••• Agrees with points made in a letter circulated from local advocacy group as sample letter of concern opposing project; makes other points of concern on water supply and quality • 153 Zingheim, Bill Port Ludlow • Project will bring jobs, better income, housing opportunities, schools, local retail, taxes; approve this project • 154 Hendricks, Eric and Joan Brinnon Refers to letter attached not found 155 Ford, Barry Port Hadlock Supports project; will bring jobs, opportunity and beauty • 156 Unruh, Doris not stated Support project; good for communities • 157 McIntyre, Vonda Duckabush River •••Concerned that promises will not be kept • 158 Hogenson, Jessica Port Ludlow •• Supports project; will help housing, jobs, local taxes • DRAFT | Page 19 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 159 Holt, David Mat Mats •• Support project; will bring jobs, services, economic base • 160 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon cover email to Record #161 161 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon • Project does not comply with GMA; it is too big and out of rural character • 162 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approve MPR. Will positively impact housing and economic development • 163 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approving MPR will attract and retain the best and brightest teachers through improved tax base • 164 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• The Pleasant Harbor MPR will provide funding for law enforcement and improve the safety and security of all county residents • 165 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approve MPR; new taxes will assist emergency services • 166 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approve project; it will provide needed jobs to help the unemployed and under employed • 167 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approve project; additional tax dollars will help address affordable housing • DRAFT | Page 20 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 168 Blair, Barbara Jo Port Townsend ••• Opposed t project. Is in wrong location for vacationers who expect nearby amenities, good weather etc. • 169 Hammond, Steve Port Ludlow •• Supports project. Will bring needed jobs, better education and increased housing • 170 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow ••• Supports project; balances the needs of the environment with sound economic growth • 171 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow ••Support project; will add to the tax base • 172 Clark, Todd Brinnon •• Oppose project; will negative impact tax base and traffic • 173 Rastelli, Jodee not stated •••••• Oppose project; cites projects impacts; project will fail and destroy ecosystem based tourism; property taxes will increase; traffic congestion will increase and cause water pollution • 174 Boettcher, Karl and Marilyn not stated •In favor of project; wish all involved success • 175 Jetliner, Lee Brinnon ••••• Opposed to project; may destroy drinking water supplies and increased wood burning will impact air quality; seasonal resort creates boom or bust and size of project will impact community • DRAFT | Page 21 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 176 Siefert, Deborah Brinnon •••••• Oppose project, will lose quality of life; concerns regarding employment, services, local costs, water supply and Hood Canal impacts; serves on MRC • 177 Robinson, D.P.Brinnon ••••• MPR will jeopardize community and environment; invest in existing people and businesses instead • 178 Icing, Charles Brinnon •••••• Impacts and expenses will not be adequately resolved especially related to traffic, public services, air quality, Hood Canal, wildlife, boating, tax increases, drinking water risks, golfing nuisances, and bankruptcy risks • 179 Cooke, Jon Quilcene • Project presents choice for local jobs, economic growth, lower poverty and reduced commuting • 180 Taylor, Jeff not stated • Golf course development is not needed; job growth not sustainable, taxes will increase and affordable housing will become worse • 181 Thompson, Rick not stated • Supports project; will address joblessness and help improve school enrollment and operations • DRAFT | Page 22 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 182 Cath cart, Wallace and V. Kay Port Ludlow •• Supports project. Will provide jobs, homes, better tax base for schools, infrastructure and local opportunities • 183 Glints, Dale Jefferson County Please support. Will have positive effects on economy and county attractiveness • 184 Farr, Karen Port Townsend Supports project; is environmentally friendly and will bring jobs, help affordable housing and local services • 185 Bergstein, Al Port Townsend •• Oppose project. No technical documentation on water processing plant and what happens if it fails • 186 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon Duplicate record of #161 187 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon Duplicate record of #187 188 Call, Roma PGST •••••• on behalf of Sullivan, Jeromy, PGST Chair; Oppose approval of development regulations and development agreement and site specific non- compliance issues related to MPR implementing ordinance • 189 Retter, Susan Port Ludlow • Supports project. Will provide desperately needed taxes • DRAFT | Page 23 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 190 Radliff, Tim not stated • Project will provide county wide benefits, is well- planned, ecologically friendly and will provide boost to many aspects of the local economy • 191 Phillips, Mari Quilcene •• Supports project; uses marina, notes improvements and thoughtful planning and that project will bring wonderful living accommodations not found elsewhere in County • 192 Mendes, Maria Kala Point Duplicate of record #142: 193 Wexman, Todd not stated Oppose project; is incompatible with preservation and enhancement of social and natural communities of Brinnon; describes how MPR will overly exclude use and rely on local taxes and investment. Not a duplicate record from #98 or #135. • DRAFT | Page 24 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 194 Mann, Cherri Port Townsend ••••••• Notes reduced size but more reduced project would further address environmental pollution concerns with water, wastewater, traffic and Hood Canal. Do not allow project to proceed; still too many environmental concerns • 195 VERBAL SUBMITTAL? C. Koan or K. Pederson?not stated •••••• Do not approve regulations or agreement and work with developer to revise project to be smaller, to preserve kettles and to protect the sensitive ecology of Hood Canal; economic development should focus on helping support and permit small, family-owned environmentally -conscious sustainable business • DRAFT | Page 25 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 196 Simmons, Donna Seabeck; Hood Canal Environmental Council ••••••• Serious concerns regarding both development agreement and development regulations; cite C. Morris' written comments on procedure, due process, build- out period, vesting. States both DA and DR do little to lessen unacceptable environmental impact concerns social economic and project financial impacts also • 197 Stern, Fred not stated •••• Project is too big and will not help local jobs, economy, environment and increase traffic accidents • 198 illegible Bales, P?Port Townsend •••••• Do not approve regulations or agreement; stormwater and water quality issues remain unresolved; Attaches and cites a 2007 comment letter on DEIS and county response; a 2015 comment letter on the DSEIS; a 2016 comment letter on the FSEIS • DRAFT | Page 26 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 199 Rose, Mark Brinnon •••••• Strongly oppose project; tribes concerns have not been addressed; project will not provide good jobs or hiring practices; property taxes will go up; water quality will be degraded and must be addressed before project proceeds; traffic accident concerns; tribal cultural concerns exist; wildlife issues unresolved. • 200 Visser, Andy Brinnon Supports project. Project will insure the health of our natural environment and welfare of our citizens; is different from submittals at #46, #82, #124 • 201 Pederson, Wally and Peggy South County •••• Project has accommodated all and many community, environmental and tribal issues and concerns; project will help tax base, local economy and community • DRAFT | Page 27 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 202 Stroh-Stern, Beth Brinnon •••••• Size of MPR out of balance for the needs of the town; traffic increase a concern; environmental damage to Hood Canal shellfish, water quality, wetlands and wildlife; tribal cultural concerns not addressed, will destroy sacred sites • 203 Stroh-Stern, Beth Brinnon ••••••• Reject this too big MPR as opposed; project will cause property taxes to go up, services to go down, poor quality jobs; traffic accidents. Revise project and downsize • 204 Pedersen, Kirie Brinnon ••••• Oppose project. Help create instead locally owned community valued economic development in proportion to remote location and fragile inland sea • 205 Koan, Cynthia Port Townsend (possibly attached to Record #204 /)Record item is a July 2016 8-page letter to the Board of Commissioners on the Planning Commission's MPR project experience 206 Pedersen, Kirie unknown (possibly attached to Record #204) print out of article entitled Saving Paradise. Winter 2017: Still Point Arts Quarterly DRAFT | Page 28 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 207 McMillan, Brenda Port Townsend •• Traffic study 9 years old and needs review. No mention of sewage treatment • 208 Coleman, Diane Brinnon •• Support project. Developer has made improvements to Maria. MPR jobs, opportunities and tax revenue needed. • 209 Fritz, James Port Townsend •• Support project. Will bring I revenue for services, help improve economy locally and countywide and help housing • 210 Schindler, Bud Brinnon Please support worthy project. Constant pressure from opposition does not represent local majority who has constantly supported project for 11 years • 211 Schindler, Valerie Brinnon •• Urge approval of project; will greatly help local services, economy, jobs and tax base.• 212 Cochrane, Julia Port Townsend •••••• Support Planning Commission; preserve kettles; ensure project's financial stability; project too large in a rural area; support HCEC monitoring concerns and traffic impacts • 213 Sullivan, Jeromy Port Gamble S'Klallam Tribe Duplicate of Record # 188 DRAFT | Page 29 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 214 Clark, Victor and Charlotte Brinnon • After reading many documents, assessments and reports developer has addressed concerns; resort will provide much needed revenue and be a community asset; provides article on outdoor recreation economy • 215 Mitchell, Robert Brinnon Duplicate of Record #146 216 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow Duplicate Record #171 217 Brinnon Group not stated Submits April 9, 2018 letter from Aramburu and Eustic, LLP to the Board on the DR and DA; a November 29, 2016 letter from Aramburu to County officials on a 2016 developer-vision; a Sept 19, 2016 letter from the developer to PGST Chair; and a April 9, 2018 letter and resume from Dave Wechner on how MPRs elsewhere have failed • 218 Cullinan, Timothy Point No Point Treaty Council ••• Discusses lack of responsiveness, adequacy and effectiveness measures for the Development Agreement wildlife management plan • DRAFT | Page 30 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 219 Ross, Rebekah and Beattie, John Hal •••• Oppose project; insufficient guarantees that impacts to drinking water and water supplies will be adequately mitigated; traffic and size/density issues not resolved • 220 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon Duplicate of Record #161 221 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon Duplicate of Record #247 222 Knoll, Roxann Brinnon •• Support project, will help community and will an asset to the community and the surrounding area; jobs and other opportunities for young people • 223 Knoll, Duane Brinnon •• project will contribute to tax base, will help provide jobs for our young people; developer will help fund additional services; this will help all County; do not know who Brinnon Group is • 224 Smith, Arnold Brinnon Totally supportive of project and wish it to be built • 225 Zingheim, Bill Brinnon Duplicate of Record #153 226 Nordland, Kathleen Nordland •Protect kettles, they are ancient sacred structures • 227 Smith, Angela Port Townsend Support project; tired of negative comments; want project built • DRAFT | Page 31 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 228 illegible Myre?, Bamli not stated Supports project; how many comment periods have there been over the last 11-12 years? • 229 Harper, John not stated Support project. Time to get moving forward, waited long enough • 230 Henderson, Douglas Port Ludlow •• Documents concerns regarding delays in project; project will help joblessness and poverty level; requests response regarding delays • 231 illegible C----not stated Support project, wants it to be built; please consider the wishes of those who live here not those who don’t • 232 LaJones, Laura (illegible)not stated Support project want my voice to be heard • 233 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •• Approving this project will help County economically in many ways; project has taken too long; represent the best interest of all County • 234 Pavel, Joseph Skokomish Tribe ••••• Submits statement reaffirming prior input on project with conditional support as long as those issues remain resolved; confirms the Skokomish Tribe Primary Right with judicial decisions attached • DRAFT | Page 32 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 235 Kaehler, Gretchen WA DAHP •• Letter to Commissioner Kate Dean regarding state agency's new comments on cultural resource values and unique and geologically significant features • 236 Burden, Lys Port Townsend •• member of native connections group concerned that large kettle will be destroyed and that tribal concerns inadequately addressed • 237 Cullinan, Timothy Point No Point Treaty Council Duplicate of record #218 238 Pedersen, Deborah Port Townsend ••••• Agrees with the Planning Commission's April 4 2018 letter especially about water quality, sewage treatment, aquifer protection, traffic and financial stability of the project • 239 Covert, Dave Port Townsend ••• Concern about the Hood Canal water quality; project should be required to improve water quality; kettles are a unique geologic feature that should be preserved • 240 Houschen, Lis Brinnon ••• Supports project; will be built to avoid impacts to wildlife and to aquifers; will provide financially healthy county • DRAFT | Page 33 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 241 Dybeck, Celeste Port Townsend ••• Jamestown S'Klallam Elder; preserve kettles, shoreline; ensure proper sewage treatment and shell and finfish protection 242 Ruzicka, Annette Port Townsend ••• Project is environmentally unsound and unsafe' too large; no guarantees for no runoff; shellfish and treaty rights are at risk; project does not protect kettles; implement the PGST shellfish mitigation plan • 243 Hals, Hansi Sequim; Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe (natural resources) •••• pre-construction monitoring of one year should be required; nutrients from golf course must be shown to have no effect; incorporate by reference PGST comments on water quality, shellfish, cultural resources and wildlife • 244 Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow •••• Notice of April 9 public hearing; comments on tax revenue, benefit to services, community safety; project represents gold standard in ecological sensitivity; will help address housing • DRAFT | Page 34 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 245 Crawford, Dennin Port Townsend ••••• Deep concern over project; runoff and pollution to Hood canal and marine environment; tribal concerns over kettles being sacred places not addressed; costs to county to build and maintain infrastructure 246 Foszcz, Roger Port Angeles Duplicate Record #112 247 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon •••••••• against project; discusses large size, number of units; visitors will bring traffic and impacts beaches; wastewaters will contain pharmaceuticals and other pollutants and road runoff; there will be trespassers; golf course not viable; resort will change rural population; no assurances for roadways, sewage systems maintenance; Hood Canal and kettles impacts huge concern; aquifer at risk; shellfish at risk; • 248 Benek, S not stated Support project; please move forward with permitting • 249 no name Concerned Citizen not stated •• opposes resort; will pollute and will compromise pristine beauty of area • DRAFT | Page 35 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 250 Blair, Barbara Jo Port Townsend Duplicate of Record #168 251 illegible Bunk, Merial not stated Support project; please move forward with permitting • 252 Millett, Lonnie Brinnon • Have reviewed documents; support smaller size; feel this will enhance area • 253 Langenbach, Michael Brinnon •••• More people in Brinnon are for project, not against; will make jobs, better services and provide revenue; project will not harm environment • 254 Langenbach, Michael Brinnon ••••• Resort is a must for Brinnon; jobs created to build and to maintain resort; better services; sewer will keep water clean; will be recreation and tax base • 255 Dean, Bill Port Ludlow • Recommends increased Highway 101 conservation easement from 10 to 30 feet 256 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon cover email to Record #257 DRAFT | Page 36 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 257 Morris, Bill and Roxianne Brinnon •••••• Post hearing observations; refers to MPR recreation/community center and other aspects that are not part of project but part of non-submitted developer vision; county should require financial assurances; MPR will raise local property taxes; MPR will not provide family wage jobs; bonding should be required; traffic will overwhelm two lane highway; Hood Canal waters will be impacted; size should be reduced; zoning to residential should be returned. • 258 Brown, Debra Brinnon Supports the building of the Master Planned Resort • 259 Longo, Al Brinnon Time to get going and approve project; tired of lies being spread by opponents • DRAFT | Page 37 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 260 McDaniel, Bonnie not stated ••••• Protect area natural resources; discharge and runoff will harm Hood Canal and aquifer and wells will be contaminated with slat water by filling up kettles; agrees with Planning Commission letter; reduce project size • 261 Johnson, Reid Brinnon •••••••• Comments are in addition to ones previously submitted; project land development and operations are incompatible with the sensitive environment of Hood Canal and Duckabush River; water quality in harbor poor; not enough being done about stormwater runoff; refers t PGST comments from May 1 2017, to Silver Tip solutions water analysis; cites PGST shellfish pollution and harvest pressure concerns and issues of increased boat traffic and noise; cites tribal significance of kettles; tribal concerns on wildlife not addressed; jobs at too low wage; project may not be financially viable • DRAFT | Page 38 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 262 Loubere, Frances Port Townsend ••• Need to value concerns of Jamestown ST and state archeologist and impacts to Brinnon clean water over gains of developing this sensitive site • 263 Cecil, Nick Duplicate of Record #275 264 Moore-Lewis, Barbara • email exchange from Kitsap resident to Moore-Lewis Brinnon Group re MPR; where to comment; knows Planning Commissioner; has opposed project in past; does not want to see light pollution from Kitsap shoreline across from project • 265 Rose, Mark Brinnon ••••• Comments on presentation provided by County at beginning of hearing; objects to it; Planning Commission should have presented; serious financial, environmental and tribal concerns; project in clear violation of GMA • DRAFT | Page 39 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 266 Gusoskey, John Quilcene ••••• Recaps testimony heard at hearing; project's benefits would start immediately and continue; objectors to project cite impacts that have been addressed; disputes concerns on traffic, wildlife; shellfish have made a comeback due to developer's work in marina • 267 Brewster, Linda not stated •••••• Agrees with PGST ad Planning Commission comments. Development phases need individual evaluation and mitigation. Sewage treatment may impact shellfish, aquifer; kettles important to tribes; jobs will be low-wage • 268 Brownell, David Sequim; Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe (cultural resources) •• Letter signed by tribal chair. Finds that project SEPA did not adequately address cultural significance of kettles and that in order to protect kettles, listing on National Register required which is unacceptable. Development agreement should require preservation of kettles and wetlands regardless. • DRAFT | Page 40 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 269 Coleman, Don Brinnon ••••••• 17-year Brinnon resident runs business dependent on good environment and economy; represents applicant; understands Ordinance 30 conditions; raises issue of tribal primacy on cultural and historic rights; objects to PGST accusations on lack of consultation; cultural significance on private property requires proof; wildlife management concerns; kettles are not ponds and do not hold water; project will conserve and recycle water; shellfish issues exist not related to proposed resort; people have not read MOUS or studies on monitoring and service agreements • 270 Moore-Lewis, Barbara Duplicate submittals from Record # 271 Cooke, J.T.Seattle •••••••• 17-page letter with attachments from developer's representative; addresses comments from public hearing and misconceptions regarding project history, current status and future permitting • DRAFT | Page 41 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 272 Zingheim, William not stated letter providing comments and observations from public hearing, county permit process and county decision- making 273 Floor, Jo Pitzer Brinnon ••••••••Form letter of objection on issues noted in bullets • 274 Floor, C.W.Brinnon ••••••••Form letter of objection on issues noted in bullets • 275 Cecil, Nick not stated • Discusses how resort could serve as human disaster relief services location by air and water access • 276 Justis, Denny Nordland •• Oppose project. Too many environmental concerns; shares concerns of environmental groups and tribes • 277 Stern, Fred Brinnon ••••• Traffic accidents will increase; kettles are sacred to natives and should not be used for waste water; will not provide dependable incomes. • 278 Loubere, Paul Port Townsend •• Inadequate consideration of cultural and environmental impacts; S'Klallam tribe has done good job analyzing flaws. Develop in a way that recognizes tribal and economic costs • 279 Stroh-Stern, Beth Duplicate Record of #203 DRAFT | Page 42 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 280 Koan, Cynthia Jefferson County' ••••••• Personal appeal. Cites confusion over EISs. Suggests adopting dev. Regs first. Dev. Agreement has little defensible substance. Port Ludlow examples discussed Inconsistent permitting decisions on Black Point and water supply. Discusses experience at another Hood Canal resort and out-of-area work force. Is disappointed that hearings, meetings not held in Brinnon. Is concerned that kettles will be used for sewage effluent and are significant to a tribes culture and livelihood. Resort is better left as is or to revert back to residential. Attaches golf course article links and verbal testimony delivered at hearing. • DRAFT | Page 43 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) 281 Smith, Lorna Port Townsend •• Planning Commission and Conservation Futures Committee. Discusses work of PCC on project. Cites RCW on existing resorts (vs proposed new), Describes issues with differences in shoreline buffer proposals. Cites DAHP comment letter and PGST consultations as warranting more work. US Army COE JD has expired and with cultural issues will trigger Sec 106 consultation. Dev. regs too broad. Long term management of easements an issue. • 282 Cohoe, Carol on behalf of Mr. Aramburu for the Brinnon Group FSEIS inadequate does not analyze alternative buildings in unofficial Vision plan (not submitted to county).Comments on proposed regulations. Cites MPRs inconsistency with Comprehensive Plan • A Watson, Jim Brinnon Notes good practices at marina; project will bring quality to community • Part I: Summary of verbal testimony received April 9, 2018 DRAFT | Page 44 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) B Smith, Lorna Jefferson County •• Discusses Planning Commission history of concerns; urged Board to deny project; there is not enough information on impacts to decide; need designed and engineered plans; described example of changes recommended to development regs on shoreline buffer and steep slopes as "careless" • C Hisey, Lynn not stated • Submitted written statement; asks Board to approve • D Clark, Charlotte not stated •Believes project has resolved environmental concerns; tax revenue will improve • E Mitchell, Bob not stated project too big, oversized; jobs are seasonal • F Hoganson, Scott not stated Project will bring revenue and improved services • G Marshall, Victoria Duckabush Estuary •Project has impressive environmental standards • H Cochran, Julia ••support protecting kettles, retain natural conditions, ensure financial stability by bonding and reduce the size • DRAFT | Page 45 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) I Brewer, Gretchen ••• References PGST letter; tribal consultations inadequate; supports Planning Commission's recommendations; protect kettles and groundwater to prevent saltwater intrusion • J Cullinan, Tim PNPTC wildlife •• Wildlife management plan is unacceptable for important reasons including specificity, enforceability and responsiveness to tribal concerns and suggestions • K name not captured Sierra Club •• Project too large and further reductions would mitigate impacts; inadequate value given to value of kettles • L D'Amore Judy Marine Resources Commission ••••read from MRC approved statement; concerns about water quality monitoring • M Hebert, Marie PGST •••• Visits Brinnon for medicinal plants; concerned about water quality, shellfish and elk; DA wildlife plan must be enforceable • N Schidler, Valerie Brinnon •Local resident, supports all aspects of project, will bring economic development • O Moses, Dale Kala Point •Continues MRC letter of concern • DRAFT | Page 46 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) P Schindler, Bud Brinnon Supports project; is compliant with Brinnon Subarea Plan; support project • Q Hammond, Steve Port Ludlow • This proposal can help the economy and protect the environment • R Marshall, David Brinnon • Urges Board to approve project; believes all Black Point septic systems will be able to connect to MPR treatment plant; shellfish will benefit • S Koan, Cynthia Port Townsend •••• Is chair of the Planning Comm. Comments are personal; reject proposal; reduce size; remove golf course; save kettles • T Ross, Rebecca lives next to MPR •••• concerned about drinking water impacts; project too big; needs financial bond; no assurance against failure environmentally and financially • U Holbert, John Brinnon ••• Developer has improved marina water quality; project will bring jobs and community services • V Schultz, Dennis not stated • Project supporter; will benefit tourism and local retail • W Fritz, James •Strongly in favor will create jobs • DRAFT | Page 47 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) X Brotherton, Tom Quilcene ••Project is environmentally sensitive; will help create jobs and benefit schools • Y Retter, Susan Port Ludlow •• Approve project; will help unemployment rate and area households • Z Cecil, Nick Brinnon • Supports project; will bring economic development to the area • AA Coleman, Diane Brinnon •• Supports project; will bring jobs and help schools and local services • BB Langenbach, Mike Brinnon •• Runs local food bank; support project; will help address poor households • CC Loomis, Bert Port Ludlow • Project has addressed all environmental concerns; process has taken too long; will generate significant jobs; approve project • DD Sickel, George Brinnon •Supports project; will bring badly needed jobs and improve local economy • EE Burns, Scott Brinnon area is beautiful; please move project forward • FF Moore, Richard Brinnon •supports projects; area needs the revenue and the jobs • GG Lacy, Gordon Brinnon •••• Project has addressed impacts; move forward to permitting to address specifics • DRAFT | Page 48 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) HH Knowl, Dwayne Brinnon •• Project will provide additional tax base for County and services; approve and let permitting address specifics • II Beattie, Hal Brinnon •••• Still has questions about project; impacts to traffic; water supply, salt water intrusion; construction noise, benefits to address south county problems; project will not help housing affordability or health care • JJ Baisch, Joe Brinnon Tribes pursue tourism; subarea plan created similar vision; Brinnon children qualify for free/reduced lunch, have low test scores; time to move forward with MPR • KK Hartley, Jackie Brinnon •• Support project; developer has responded to issues; project will provide recreation; taxes will help school and services • LL Rullivan (sp), Tim Port Ludlow MPR is important to economically depressed community • MM Sullivan, Stephanie PGST •••••• Hood Canal cannot be restored once it is destroyed; think about future generations, be responsible; 890 units will pollute beaches • DRAFT | Page 49 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) NN Price, Laura PGST •••• think about future generations; understands need for development; please continue meaningful consultations to ensure no impacts to Hood Canal; look to the future • OO Peterson, Doug Brinnon ••• Why so many delays/ Time to move forward; project has shown it will be good for community and for environment • PP Murdoch , Rowan (sp)PGST •• do not want the resort there; do not turn Pleasant Harbor into Seattle; want to be able to pick berries there; golf course will prevent that • QQ Visser, Andy Brinnon ••••Project is environmentally fine-tuned; project will provide for young families; will provide entry-level jobs • RR Hogan, Dennis Brinnon ••• County needs tax base to protect environment; doesn't see county doing monitoring and code enforcement; need to find balance, move this on to the next stage • SS Dunham, Ruth Brinnon •• Brinnon is a food desert; need food services; need this project, vote yes • DRAFT | Page 50 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) TT Rose, Mark Brinnon ••• Involved in subarea plan; appealed MPR so that EIS happened; tribes concerns still not addressed; jobs will not benefit community, project will not help local economy • UU Wilke, Jodi not stated •• Complimented planning commission; project will provide jobs, tourism, restaurants, help local farms and provide property taxes • VV inaudible Kusowski, John (?)not stated ••• Good reasons for and against project; environmental impacts appear to be addressed; support project • WW Simmons, Donna Hoodsport •••• Hood Canal Env Council rep.;Dev. Agreement has to be consistent with regulations, work on dev. regs. first; there is confusion as to the versions of dev. Regs - Planning Commission versus the county staff version; concern with build out period; seems perpetual; inadequate handling of kettles, wildlife management, water quality monitoring; require bond • DRAFT | Page 51 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) XX Moore-Lewis, Barbara not stated • Refers to letter from attorneys, from developer, to and from PGST, from a land use planner; discusses financial failures of other resorts; require bonding; protect citizens and assets • YY Sullivan, Jeromy Chair, PGST ••• Oppose the project as proposed; tribe supports responsible development; 890 units too much; PGST concerns have not been addressed; Brinnon ancestral village for PGST; water quality monitoring not specific enough • ZZ Ashworth, Donovan PGST •• Opposes project; what happens to salmon and shellfish if something goes wrong • AAA Peterson, Kirie Brinnon ••••• Oppose project. Help create instead locally owned community valued economic development in proportion to remote location and fragile inland sea (submits article Saving Paradise) • BBB inaudible Beth not stated ••• Project will create burdens on infrastructure costs and services; jobs will be all at low income; oppose current plan; need guarantees • DRAFT | Page 52 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) CCC Cecil, Marla Brinnon ••Is worried about water quality if this moves forward; spoke in support; need jobs • DDD Mendez, Maria Kala Point •••Commented on monitoring plan. Population and traffic too much • EEE Miland, Bambi Brinnon •• Drug use is everywhere in Brinnon. Not enough police help. We need this project. It will bring help and improve the community • FFF Langenbach, Elouise Brinnon •• Runs local food bank; support project; help children and poor households; closest grocery thirty miles away; environment is protected • GGG Knowl, Roxanne Brinnon •• does not understand opposition; project is needed; will bring revenue, local spending and support public services • HHH Mardelene, Marlene Brinnon •• Developer has done a good job cleaning up water quality in marina. Project will bring much needed commerce to area. • III Mardelene, Marvin Brinnon ••• Oyster beds have returned to marina. Approve project. Brinnon could die like other rural towns near Mt. Rainier • DRAFT | Page 53 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) JJJ Peterson, Peggy not stated •Need job opportunities; please support project • KKK Murdoch , Miriam not stated •••• State guidelines on impacts of MPRs referenced; project will impact water quality, shellfish, traffic, has read sub area plan • LLL Purser, Stormy PGST • using kettles for wastewater is disrespectful; tribe concerns were dismissed; county does not have the right to say wat is culturally significant; sees need for growth; keep Brinnon beautiful, oppose resort • MMM Coleman, Samantha not stated • works for marina; also works with area youth; this resort will provide programs for kids • NNN Toeper, Dan Port Ludlow Need balance; available land is shrinking • OOO Bahls, Peter not stated •• Represents Northwest Watershed Institute; dev. Agreement is a contract and needs to be specific; water supply and quality a concern • DRAFT | Page 54 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) PPP Call, Roma PGST •• Project needs a smaller footprint; development agreement is not ready; needs more accountability; does not comply with ordinance conditions; lacks mitigation; concerned about promises to citizens • QQQ Talbott, Tim Brinnon ••• local builder; water quality vastly improved in marina; oysters returned; developer has rights as property owner • RRR Coleman, Don Brinnon ••••• Developer has met all conditions outlined in 2008; project is economically sound and economically beneficial; we need this • SSS Giske, Tom Port Ludlow ••• Planning Commission member; letter is not based on opposition; believes project can be revised to provide better predictability; is concerned about loss of plants and animals in kettles • TTT Hartley, Larry Brinnon Worked for Pleasant Harbor over the years; Get this project done • DRAFT | Page 55 of 55 Comment #Name Location or Affiliation Summarized Comment of note P N WQ SH AQ/WS CR WF CA TR PS SZ EC Topic abbreviations: WQ-water quality; SH-shellfish; AQ/WS-aquifer, water supply; CR-tribal/cultural, archeology. or historic resources; WF-wildlife; CA-critical areas including Topic(s) UUU Cooke, JT not stated ••••• Represents developer; county role now is to adopt development regs. Consistent with comp. plan MPR designation; state law defines MPR densities greater than what Pleasant Harbor proposing; project provides on-site zero discharge waster water treatment at Class A standards; 105 acres permanently preserved; all future permitting must comply with standards, mitigation measures outlined in ordinance and development agreement; traffic studies met standards; cultural resource work substantial • VVV Mann, Garth not stated •••• Is developer; numerous public hearings on project; we have spent a lot of effort to consult with PGST; we have spent a lot of effort addressing environmental concerns; we are proud of our work and results; want to create a quality project; investments, economic activity and revenue from project will be substantial • WWW inaudible Klass, Johann not stated everyone needs to get along