HomeMy WebLinkAboutLog065
r
-,....
e
e
Josh Peters
Subject:
Nicole Faghin [nfaghin@reidmidd,com]
Thursday, October 11, 2001 10:31 AM
shaffjas@dfw.wa.gov
jpeters@co,jefferson,wa,us; Edwin ,J ,Gossett@ NW S02, usace,army .mil;
MDorsey@portludlowassociates,com; Keri Adams-Lee; Lyn Keenan; Shannon Kinsella
Scoping comments, Re: Port Ludlow Revisions
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
.
Nicole Faghin. vef
Anne, I'll try to clarify the drawing. But I'll start with a side
note. We spent HOURS trying to figure out how to tell the story in one
drawing. So your comments, as we feared, indicate we still haven't
found the right combo of colors, text, etc. Based on your comments,
we'll try to adjust this before tomorrow's scoping meeting. Because if
its confusing to you, then the rest of the public will DEFINITELY be
confused.
Now the attempt to clarify: The areas that are blue with red hatching
are in both the 2000 and 2001 proposal, including the kayak grated float
(no change from 2000). The BLUE ONLY is in the 2000 proposal and now
deleted. The RED HATCHED is in the 2001 proposal. We tried to
differentiate the areas changed by adding a DARK LINE around those
portions of the Marina that may have changed.
Change in over water coverage is 359 SF additional out of a TOTAL NEW
overwater coverage of 32,136 SF proposed in the 2000 project. That
means the changes increased the total new overwater coverage by 1%.
The comments from the Colbys will be addressed during the SEPA process.
Hope this helps!
Nicole Faghin
Director of Planning
and Environmental Services
Reid Middleton
728 134th St. SW
Everett, WA 98204
(425) 741-3800
Fax: (425) 741-3900
nfaghin@reidmidd.com
>>> Anne Shaffer <shaffjas@dfw.wa.gov> 10/11/01 10:05AM >>>
Josh,
Additional scoping comments included in the following, thanks....
Thanks Nicole,
The attached files were the most use (the faxed letter is in black and
white). A few more points. On the figures it is impossible to tell
which elements are in addition to the 2000 proposal and which are in
place of the 2000 proposal (see key for quick illustration). To clarify,
the portions of the plan that are the blue 2000 proposal, are now
dropped? The blue with red outline and hatching overlay are both 2000
and
2001, and the red hatching is additional 2001 proposal, correct?
If this is so, by my quick review it looks like there is a new kayak
float, which will need to be moved deeper than -20 even with grating
I }~
'u"
LOG ITEM
f;;c;
{ of ~_
1
'''qe
and~ r~vised so it is as naJltw as possible (see Fresh and W~iams
press. Bottom line, on water grating doesn't work... These authors
work in 1995 documented that anything over 2 meters wide impacted
nearshore habitat.).
in
same
On your table, please clarify what the net increase in overwater
structure of the 2001 proposal is from the existing facility (not the
2000 proposal), and what depths the increased overwater structure
occupies. This will need to be: l)minimized to the absolute possible,
and no increase in over water structure may occur shallower than -15
MLLW. Once all minimizing/avoiding has taken place, and it is confirmed
that no
eelgrass will be impacted, if there is any additional increase in
overwater coverage (again which may only occur deeper than -15MLLW)
than we will need to discuss a minimum of 2:1 mitigation. I have offered
mitigation options in the past, including moving existing in and
overwater structure, including, the gas float offshore.
I also received a letter of comments from Colby and concur with water
quality concerns, including pump out station capacity and locations.
These should be addressed.
I may have more comments as I receive additional clarifying information.
Formal copy of this input will follow shortly. Look forward to
replys. . . JAS .
Nicole Faghin wrote:
> Anne and Jack:
>
> You will be receiving a letter today from Port Ludlow Associates
restarting our permitting process. Along with that letter is a drawing
showing the existing marina, the layout proposed in the 2000 JARPA and
the new layout (2001). I'm sending you an email of those drawings in
PDF format so you can see the full effect of the color drawings showing
all those differences. Please let me know if you have any questions.
>
> Nicole Faghin
> Director of Planning
> and Environmental Services
> Reid Middleton
> 728 134th St. SW
> Everett, WA 98204
> (425) 741-3800
> Fax: (425) 741-3900
> nfaghin@reidmidd.com
>
>
> Name: 4914c.pdf
> 4914c.pdf Type: Portable Document Format (application/pdf)
> Encoding: base64
>
>
> COLOR Chart (1) .pdf
(application/pdf)
>
>
Name: COLOR Chart (1) .pdf
Type: Portable Document Format
Encoding: base64
> Name: Nicole Faghin.vcf
> Nicole Faghin.vcf Type: VCard (text/x-vcard)
> Encoding: quoted-printable
Dlaj:ta
2
LOG ITEiVI
&)--
).'"'oe (j- oC~
Jl
"~ .~