Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLog090 .< -. ,./ \'\\ \' cc', , . '~ " \ DATE: TO: CC: FROM: RE: / LOG ITEiVI #~O Page j of Jh. MEMO APR 2 1 2004 ~~f::':-;~;:~ p:: I ~:r~' .. ;;~\...~ April 17, 2004 JEFFERSON COUNTY OCD Michelle Farfan, Associate Planner, Jefferson County Al Scalf, David Goldsmith, David Alverez, BOCC, Randi Thurston WDFW, Jeff Davis WDFW, Jeffree Stewart DOE, Paula Mckrow NOSC, Richard Brocksmith HCCC, Doug Soehl TU, Carol Saber PL VC, Dwayne Wilcox PL VC, Jeff Schreck DNR, LBV Homeowners Bert Loomis a) b) Port Ludlow Resort Plan Revision - Draft SEIS, 3/15/04 Shoreline Primary Use Substantial Development Permit No, SDP 91-017, issued 5/11/93 Dear Michelle: After reading the Shoreline Management Master Program [SMMP] for Jefferson County, along with the two documents referred to above, it appears that the SEIS contains fatal flaws that are violations of the SMMP, The SEIS proposes to increase density by approximately 66%, with the majority of these units being constructed on pilings over the lagoon, See SEIS Figures 7 A, 7C & 12A, Please review the SMMP Pages 69 & 70, Section 5.160, Residential Development: Prohibited Uses and Activities 1, Residential structures located on or over marshes, bogs, swamps, lagoons, tidelands, ecologically sensitive areas or water areas subject to this Master Program. Policies 4. Over-water residential development, including floating homes, should not be permitted, Performance Standards 5. Developments containing marshes, swamps, lagoons, portions of a flood plain, or similar wetlands shall use those areas only for the purpose of parks, open space, or recreational facilities. , . Also, the following permit conditions clearly indicate any construction over the lagoon will be inconsistent with, and contrary to, the intent of at least ten mitigation conditions of the existing Permit SDP91-017, dated May 11, 1993, as previously agreed to by the County and Developer. Development pursuant to this permit shall be undertaken subject to the applicable policies and performance standards of the Jefferson Shoreline Management Master Program and the following conditions: 13. Eelgrass (zostra marina) shall be planted in the eastern sector of the pond to prevent the growth of sea lettuce (ulva). 14. During construction, water levels in the on-site pond shall be lowered and sediment removed therefrom prior to the discharge of water into the Bay. 15, Two pumps shall be installed in the pond for redundancy in case of failure and to improve flexibility for periodic maintenance. A standby mobile power generator shall be provided in the event of power outages. 16, The maintenance schedule for the pond shall avoid pump shutdown during warmer weather, thereby lessening stagnation of water and related water quality problems. 21. Landscape design and planting materials for the perimeter of the pond shall minimize the need for herbicide application, Native plant materials shall be utilized to the maximum extent throughout the entire project site to reduce the use of fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides, When the application of such chemicals is necessary, they shall only be applied by state - licensed personnel. 22. Buffers of grasses, low growing plants, shrubs, and trees shall be planted along the shoreline and around the pond, providing habitat, water quality enhancement, and protection from human disturbance, 24, Enlargement of the existing pond shall make provisions for improved aeration and circulation to discourage algae growth, maintain consistent water quality, and improve its value as fish habitat. 27, The weir outlet to the pond shall be designed to prevent fish entrapment in the pond, 28. The pond shall be designed to provide some shallow area along the south shoreline, suitable for wading birds, isolated from public access. 2 29. Pond shoreline length equivalent to at least 50% of the existing shoreline length shall be provided for bird loafing area, This shoreline area must be buffered by landscape vegetation to discourage public disturbance. This permit was issued subject to significant mitigation requirements. The applicant now wants to increase density by 66%, while concurrently violating previously agreed to permit conditions, I call your attention to the Notice Section of the Permit: 1, This permit may be rescinded by the Jefferson County Board of Commissioners or the Washington State Shorelines Hearings Board upon finding the Developer has not complied with the conditions herein, pursuant to RCW 90,58,140 (8), 2. .. ,Construction or substantial progress toward construction of the permitted development shall begin within two (2) years from the date of this permit and completion of the permitted development shall be accomplished within five (5) years from the date of this permit... This Permit was issued on May 11, 1993 and completion was to have been accomplished by May 11, 1998, To date, 11 years later, less than 44% of the development has been completed. As you know, serious questions have been raised concerning the Developer's failure to comply with many of the current permit conditions, I call your attention the SEIS, Appendix C, Landscape Plan Port Ludlow Resort by GeoEngineers [2/04]. The consultant acknowledges a failure to comply with conditions of the Permit to date: Appendix C 1.0 Introduction, , ,This conceptual landscape plan has been prepared to assist PLA in satisfying the mitigation requirements,. ,to lessen project impacts and enhance environmental conditions at the Port Ludlow Resort, 4,1 South Lagoon Shoreline - Wildlife Area" ,This will address one of the requirements in the 1993 shoreline conditions." 4.3.4 Eelgrass (zostera marina) .. .One of the conditions of the 1993 shoreline permit for the Port Ludlow Resort states that "Eelgrass shall be planted in the eastern sector of the pond"." to date that has not been accomplished. 4.4 Esplanade and Walking Paths ,., a plan for connecting these trails with parking facilities and other public access routes is under development. . . 3 Why are they still planning for the required mitigation conditions eleven years after the permit has been issued? Also, see SEIS Page 3-21, Section 3.3,1, Affected Environment: Artificial Lagoon The lagoon was initially constructed in 1967 by excavating upland soils, It was 1.4 acres in size. In 1994 the lagoon was expanded to 2,2 acres as mitigation for planned Resort expansion, Based on the Applicant's clear failure to comply with Section 5,160 of the Shoreline Management Master Program for Jefferson County, I request that you reject their Draft SEIS. Also, I expect the County to fully enforce all conditions of Permit SDP 91-017 and the SMMP as required by law, Contact: Bert Loomis 9500 Oak Bay Road Port Ludlow, W A 98365 360-437-2400 bertl@cablespeed,com End: Permit SDP91-017 with conditions Figure 7 A SEIS Figure 7C SEIS Figure 12A SEIS 4 JEFFERSON COUNTY SHORELINE SUBSTANTIAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT WASHINGTON STATE SHORELINE MANAGEMENT ACT (ReW 90.58) /4647 . . PERMITTEE: Pope Resources DATE ISSUED: May 11, 1993 TYPE OF ACTION: General TYPE OF USE: Primary, Secondary, Conditional CASE NUMBER: SDP91-017 APPLICATION DATE: August 7, 1991 , PROPOSAL: A residential, commercial, and recreational development consisting of the following: . * A 36-room hotel; * 5 detached single family residences and 53 attached single family residences in 14 multi-unit structures; * Roadways and 367 parking spaces; * utilities, including water, electrical power, and sanitary sewer ; * 500 cubic yards of rip rap shore defense works; * Marina modifications including a new manager's .building, new restrooms and laundry, new fuel and propane tanks located between the marina and the pond, and removal of an existing boat launch; * Landscaping and recreational amenities inclUding construction of vegetated artificial dunes on the'southerly portion of the.spi~, trails and a pedestrian bridge, outdoor sport courts, and expansion of the existing pond; * Approximately 45,000 cubic yards of filling including 25,000 cubic yards for * Temporary and permanent soil erosion management system; * Directional and informational signs; * Outdoor lighting; and * 10.5 acres of undeveloped open space. excavation, grading and pond expansion; control and storm 'water The Inn would be a,three-story, wood frame structure, that would include a manager's.:residence. Its maximum height would be 52 feet. It would have a foot print of 11,345 square feet and total square footage of 34; 171 square .feet. Its design would include the following fire and life safety features: quick-response sprinkler heads; automatic alarm notice to Fire District #3; tamper protection for the automatic sprinkler system; hose cabinets at each floor; diesel generator back-Up power source; an indicator panel for all building safety systems; ,smoke detection on HVAC systems; a stairwell to the roof; and a wet-sprinkler in the covered drive-through. The proponent also proposes planning and staff training in order to enable rapid respond to emergencies. Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 Pope Resources The existing man-made pond covering 1.4 acres would b~ enlarged to 2.2 acres. A pump would supply with water from Ludlow Bay in order to maintain a'constant salinity. A new 800 square foot marina manager's office would be constructed midway between the existing office and the Inn site. The existing office would be demolished and replaced with newrestrooms and laundry facilities on the same site. The e~isting underground fuel and propane tanks-would be removed and new tanks would be located adjacent to the manager's office in a containment bunker. Exterior lighting fixtures would employ hoods, shades, or dther techniques to direct illumination onto the immediate area where it is needed. Light standards in parking areas would not exceed 10 feet in height. Light fixtures along pedestrian walkways would not exceed 4 feet in height. No colored lights would be used except for holiday occasions. utilities would be installed underground. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: The proposal site comprises 17.5 acres adjacent to the existing marina and resort at Port Ludlow and is described as ,portions of Government Lots 1 and 2 in section 16, Township 28 North, Range 1 East ,.'W.M.- . , WATERBODY AND/OR ASSOCIATED WETLANDS: Port Ludlow Bay SHORELINE OF STATE-WIDE SIGNIFICANCE: No SHORELINE DESIGNATION: Urban CONDITIONS: Oevelopment pursuant to this permit ~hall be undertaken subject to the applicable' policies and performance standards of the Jefferson-Port Townsend Shoreline Management Master Program and the following conditions: . J 1. A detailed erosion and sedimentation .control plan using the best management practices set forth in the Washington Department of Ecology's storm Water Manual for the puaet Sound Basin shall be prepared in conjunction with final site design and a construction phasing schedule. Grading on the project site shall not begin until the er~sion control plan has been approved by the Director of the Jefferson County Department of Public Works or his design~e. The objectives of said plan are to (a) control dust and mud and stabilize the construction area including entrances and roadways; (b) prevent surface . 2 Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 Pope Resources ../ 2. -.j 3. ,. v 4. ..; 5. .../ 6. .f 7. water runoff from eroding areas to be cleared and graded; (c) prevent sedimentation from entering the waters of Port Ludlow Bay. Erosion control techniques may include, but are not limited to, piped slope drains, subsurface drains, hydroseeding, surface roughening, interceptor dikes and berms, check dams, swales, gradient terraces, rip-rap, gravel filter berms, storm drain inlet and outlet protection, and filter (silt) fences. A maintenance program shall be implemented during the course of construction to insure the proper and effective functioning of erosion and sedimentation control features. Inspection of erosion control features shall be conducted daily. ' Soil disturbance associated with, major grading activities shall conform to t~e guidelines and timing restrictions set forth in the Washington State Department of Ecology Storm- Water Manaqement Manual (current edition). Prior to final plat approval and prior to any clearing and grading on the site, the proponent shall submit a construction phasing plan to the Jefferson County Public Works Department for review and approval. The plan shall specify how the proponent proposes. to achieve the goals of this mitigation measure. Dur ing construction, to the extent practicable, existing vegetation shall be maintained on those portions of the site planned as permanent open space. only during the course of utility installation or revegetation/landscaping shall disturbance occur. Grading stockp~les shall be located on the uphill side of excavation areas to act as runoff diversions. Any large stockpiles shall be shaped and covered or seeded. Soil, sediment, water, or debris generated during pond enlargement shall be confined to specific areas on the site as identified. on. the erosion control plan. Dredged pond material and other site material unsuitable for project fill- shall be disposed of at a location approved by the Director of the Jefferson county Department of Public Works. Following construction, all cleared and graded areas shall be permanently revegetated according to .an overall landscape plan. Revegetation shall be completed as soon as practicable after grading and construction is,complete. Dunes proposed for the Inn area shall be stabilized ,through the use of vegetation and underlying foundations so as to minimize sand and soil redistribution during storm events. 3 Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 Pope Resources .j 8. " 9. J . The proponent shall designate a qualified, trained, and experienced individual or firm who shall ensure that (a) erosion control .devices are correctly installed; (b) inspection and maintenance schedules are regularly k~pt; (c) corrective actions are employed in the event erosion control measures fail to perform effectively and (d) reports and inspections are coordinated with the Jefferson County Department of Public Works. A complete geotechnical investigation. shall be undertaken on slopes steeper than 15% where buildings or infrastructure are proposed. Particular attention will be paid to possibilities of earthquake-induced subsidence or liquefaction. Structures' shall be designed, engineered, and constructed in conformance with the Uniform Building Code, other adopted standards pertaining to landslide 'and seismic hazard protection, and specific construction practices recommended by the geotechnical consultant. The consultant shall be a qualified professional selected and paid by the project proponent. No construction of buildings, or installation of infrastructure on slopes steeper than 15% shall take place. prior to completion of the geotechnical investigation. . A permanent stormwater drail)age system shall be installed, the design and construction of which shall be to the satisfaction .' of the Department of Public .Works. system.components~sha~l include grass-lined swales, oil/water separators, and a detention pond to manage both water quantity and quality. ..../' 11. The project's stormwater management system shall be incorporated into the ongoing Port Ludlow Bay "water"Quality Monitoring Program -: Nonpoint Sources". v' 12. A maintenance program shall be developed for pil/water separators and biofilters and approved by the Jefferson County Department of Public Works. . 10. V' 13. Eelgrass (zostra marina) shall be planted in the eastern sector of the pond to prevent the growth of sea lettuce (Ulva) . / 14. During construction, water levels in the on-site pond shall be lowered and sediment removed therefrom prior to the discharge of water into the Bay. " 15. Two pumps shall be installed in the pond for redundancy in case of failure and to improve flexibility for periodic 4 ... Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 Pope Resources J 19. Groundwater seepage encountered during construction in 'upland areas shall be directed by sloping excavations to shallow sump pits. Any collected water shall be discharged to the construction-phase stormwater control system. , \ : \~\(- Portions of structures subject to periodic tidal inundation shall be sited and constructed in'compliance with Jefferson County's "Flood Plain Management Ordinance No. 1-89." J 21. Landscape design and planting materials for the perimeter of the pond shall minimize the need for herbicide applicatiol). Native plant materials shall be utilized to the maximum extent' throughout the entire project site to reduce the use of fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides. When the application \~.of such chemicals is necessary, they shall only be applied by ~i state-~icensed personnel. 20. ..j 22. Buffers of grasses, low growing plants, shrubs, and trees shall be planted along the shoreline and around ~pe pond, providing habitat, water quality 'enhancement, and protection from human disturbance. . j 23.' Primary landscape materials planted on, the site shall be those native trees, shrubs, grasses, and herbaceous cover which provide food and cover for wildl.ife, for example, Douglas firs, We~tern red cedars, vine maples, wax myrtles, and wild strawberries. .J 24. Enlargement of the existing pond' shall make provisions for improved aeration and circulation to discourage algae growth, maintain consistent water quality, and improve its value as fish habitat. 5 Shoreline Substantial Development Pe~it SDP91-017 Pope Resources . J 25. Interpretive signs shall be installed at pertinent points throughout the site to describe important habitat features and wildlife. Pamphlets and brochures shall be distributed to residents and guests to increase awareness and respect for wildlife which inhabit the project site. - J 26. Filtration shall be provided at the pump water-intake pipes to reduce the incidental capture of fish. v 27. The weir outlet to the pond shall be designed to prevent fish entrapment in the pond. v 28. The pond shall be designed to provide some shallow area along the south shoreline, suitable for wading birds, isolated from public access. ' ../ 29. Pond shoreline length equivalent to at least 50% of the existing shoreline length shall be provided for bird loafing area. This shoreline area must be buffered by landscape vegetation to discourage public disturbance. " 30. Excavation shall be minimized to reduce encountering contaminated soil materials development of the site. J 31. Lead concentrations from previous testing in the vicinity pf Test pit 10 (TP-10) shall be reported to the Washington Department of Ecology if encountered in quantities in excess of 10 cubic yards. . potential for from previous .J . ../ 32. Excavated soils at locations other than TP-10 shall be, monitored for presence of potentially hazardous materials. v 33. In accordance with DOE Policy #101 (Site piscovery aud Release Reporting), a qualified hazardous waste specialist shall be contacted if more than 10 cubic yards of charcoal-like material is encountered in order' to prop~rly assess implications for disposal. 34. Prior to initiating excavation, a qualified haza+dous waste specialist shall orient the construction contractors and crew regarding field identification of, potentially contaminated soil and materials. .'- -v -, ,~ . ....\J. ,'v ..j 35. The proponent shall establish legally enforceable- architectural design guidelines which address such matters as roof materials, siding, exterior colors, appurtenances, and 6 Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-01.7 Pope Resources ,,/ 36. v 37. ,//' ./ 38. ,; 39. . ~"" ,~" . . I' l'. ... il~-- .. .~~.' .....', -..l....' '\ '.. v_. v I " 40. j 41.. -' 42. other factors that affect the overall aesthetic Gharacter of the project site. The proponent shall comply with all regulations of the State Shoreline Management Act (RCW 90.58), RCW 217.44.0.40, RCW 27.53.060 and WAC 25-489 regarding archaeological sites. These regulations prohibit intentional disturbance of archaeological or burial sites without prior approval and provide protocols for actions following discovery of such sites. Prior to excavation, a qualified archaeologist shall orient the construction contractors and crews in identification of potential archaeological resources that might be uncovered, and how to proceed in the event of an unexpected'discovery. If cultural resources are discovered during construction, a qualified archaeologist shall be immediately dispatched to systematically analyze the findings. All construction or excavation on that portion of the project site shall immediately cease and measures shall be taken to prevent further disturbance prior to analysis by a qualified archaeologist. The following above-code fire and life safety features shall be provided in the Inn structure: quick-response sprinkler heads; . automatic alarm notice to Fire District' #3; tampe,r protection for the automatic sprinkler system; hose cabinets at each floor; diesel generator back-up power source; an indicator pane~ for 'all building safety systems; smoke detection on HVAC systems; interior stairway to the roof; and a wet-sprinkler in the covered drive-through. . The proponent shall develop a plan for the Inn which identifies applicable emergency, actions to be tak~n during such unlikely events as fires or earthquakes. The staff shall be trained in fire behavior, built-in fire and life safety systems in the Inn structure~ and proper re~ponses to emergencies and safety needs of all ~ests. A maintenance schedule for fire and life safety equipment shall be developed. All such equipment. and related systems shall be tested at least annually in cooperation with Jefferson County Fire District, No.3. Records of all maintenance and system tests shall be retained at the Inn and copies transmitted to Jefferson County Fire District No.3. Exit maps and instructions on emergency procedures shall be 7 ~' Shoreline Substantial Development Permit , SDP91-017 Pope Resources installed on the inside of all guest room doors.. J 43. A public relations videotape which emphasizing building safety' features, guest responsibilities for safety in shall be available in all guest rooms. includes. a prologue exit locations, and emergency sit.':lations V 44. The Inn's resident manager and all other on-site staff, as a condition of employment, should be trained in basic first aid and CPR. J 45. Fundamental emergency aid equipment shall be provided at the Inn for staff use. 46. In order to assess cumulative impacts from this project, the proponent shall: (a) continue the existing Water Oualitv Monitorinq Proqram which documents nonpoint source effects on the Class A "Extraordinary" designation of Port Ludlow Bay and it's tributaries. Sampling shall include the water column, sediments, and shellfish as appropriate. If monitoring indicates that activities of the, proponent- are causing reduction in the water quality of Port Ludlow Bay below the Class AA "Extraordinary" designation, the proponent. shall inundiately so advise Jefferson County. The "scope of work" for each year's program shall.be conducted where necessary to obtain the most meaningful scientific data. The ensuing year's scope of work shall be approved by Jefferson county each autumn. Each year's monitoring results shall be reported to Jefferson county by March 15 of the following yepr. The proponent shall be responsible' for employing a qualified water quality research firm at proponent's sole expense. (b) Conduct a Water Resource Monitorinq Proqram which documents the condition of several aquifers utilized as a domestic source by the proponent. Attention should be focused on static groundwater levels and saltwater intrusion. Should groundwater monitoring indicate an inadequate yield to support development of the proponent's proj ects in the context of water rights and projected water use, the pr9pqnent shall immediately inform the County and take' necessary action to insure an adequate supply of potable water. This action could include, but is not limited to, development of additional sources, supplementation of existing sources, and/or implementation of additional conservation measures. If mutually agreeable, the proponent shall include Olympus 8 Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91.-017 Pope Resources /\~ :f'.. 'Ii 47 . 'J -.~,O( ( tl" .~ ,-.1 ,,)' ... 1\' '....." ''':'' ~, .'11,. .' ,'";. ",,4 8 . ..' -, \' ..... 49. ,./. ,;,:. ,~.t.j' ,....;./ \..' ,~ ::) '_ -. ".~f ~ , \ ".....' .......\': .. ~., \.- ../ 50. ~iJ. ~'1\,,4 " , ~\\~~l \v I);~ -J 51. Beach Tracts' wells in ongoing groundwater monitoring efforts. . The proponent shall be responsible for employing a qualified geohydrologist to.design, direct, and conduct said monitoring program. The expense of said geohydrologist shall be the proponent's. Results of the monitoring program shall be reported to Jefferson County and the Washington Department or Ecology by March 15 of each year. (c) Conduct a Sewaqe Treatment Plant Monitorinq Proqram which documents effects of the proponent's ,projects on capacity of the secondary wastewater treatment plant. Attention shall be focused on the number of connections; effluent flow volume; and effluent quality. It is acknowledged that the ,sole authority to monitor and regulate operation of the sewage, treatment plant rests with the Washington Department of Ecology. Nothing in this condition is intended to supersede or conflict with requirements of the proponent's National Pollution Discharge Elimination system (NPDES) Permit No. WA- 002120-2 issued pursuant to the Federal Clean Water Act and companion statutes. If any function or value monitored by the NPDES permit is exceeded, notice shall be prov.ided to Jefferson County concurrently with notice to the Washington Department of Ecology. Results of the monitoring contained in this condition shall be transmitted, to Jefferson County and the Washington Department of Ecology by March 15 of, each year.- The riprap shore defense work shall be constructed 'in ~ubstantial alignment'with the ordinary high water mark. . . Design of the fuel and propane tanks shall be approved by the Chief of Fire District No.3. The deed to the homeowners association from Pope Resources of Tracts A, C, and M-1 shall be subject to' an easement in favor of the general public for access, use, and enjoymeht for th~ life of the project. The association will retain the right ~o reasonably regulate those common areas by establishing rules and regulations., such as those to protect lanscaping, regulate noise, prevent nuisances. ' Informational and directional signs shall clearly indicate the location of public access areas. The proponent shall provide near 'the marina loading area an access area and stairway to facilitate launching of small watercraft such as di~ghies, canoes, and kayaks. 9 . . Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 Pope Resources . NOTICE: . 1. This permit may be rescinded by the Jefferson 'county Board of Commissioners or the Washington State Shorelines 'Hearings Board upon the finding the permittee has not complied with the conditions herein, pursuant to RCW 90.58.140(8). 2. The permittee is liable for all damages to public and private property arising from violation of any provisions of the permit hereby granted, including the cost 'of restoring the affected area to its condition prior to violation and possible court costs that may ensure from violation, pursuant to RCW 90.58.230. ' 3. Construction pursuant to this permit will not begin nor is to authorized until thirty (30) days from the date of filing as defined in RCW 90.58. 140(6) and WAC 173-14-090, or until all review proceedings initiated within thirty days from the date of such filing have terminated, except as provided in RCW 90.58.140(5.a-c). Construction or substantial progress toward construction of the permitted development shall begin within two (2) years from the date of this permit and completion of the permitted development shall be accomplished within five (5) years from the date of this p~rmit. 4. Nothing in this permit shall excuse the permittee from compl ing with any other federal, state, or local statutes, ~nan s, or regulations applicable to this projec~, but consisten ith R W 9 .5 , 10 . , ., Shoreline Substantial Development Permit SDP91-017 pope Resources THIS SECTION IS CONDITIONAL USE USE ONLY IN REGARD TO A . FOR DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY PERMIT OR A VARIANCE. . /11 a V I ., .) L/('/ Date received by the Department: Approved: "f Denied \~3 This conditional use permit/v1u. .i.~IP p is approved/dwll.i.oQd by the Department pursuant to Chapter 90.58 RCW. Development shall be undertaken pursuant to the following. additional terms and conditions: ~~ ~l"IA-e Hbl)LellE:.R- , C:\SDP\SDP91017.Per 11 , ~- t4 -~ Date . . - Port Ludlow Resort Plan DSEIS , r . . I I I I I 1 'I -I I -I -I -I IEZ 1 I '-- ~, '. -- -~-- , ":.//, - - ./ " ii, ",', ., '" ".~ \~ \ \ ~" \.. \. ...,' \,. \. . :':"\ ..~y\ ':,.' : '\ \ ". . ' , m -I . -.-....... "--, 'ii (/ . ve s::: ra - D. ~ Q) :> s::: o .- ..f-I V OJ '" .. U ii e_ E o q =s '0 E I/) i r~ I -j I I I o N 1 ..- i ,_ I r-- -- 1--- ! ; L.u, _ , " I i I i _~'H ~ I 1 _ ___ r---i , 1- I--l~-' I ! i L__ ___ L o N o IX) o o ~ , o ~ C i; L ~'S',- z W Q.. o t" 7't_ \ --.\ ---~"'uu41 0_ \ -Q:-' . !-=.~~ -.:" 6'';: t o co .+ fz~ ' ~ ,N - -- - - -- - -- - --z w, _~ :...::~.::l.:,.:..:..:._ "'~'6 I . i LL I. '0 I it' , I L_u'-u ..- ---- --_.,;---'j : z ;--- I'~ , 0 I ; ~'I j-- ! ! -' "., . . ,-'..,..-, . . 'I; '----'-., -, ; 0 9 . -:-+--r--;- j , ___~ ~ ! -'~I J~~r- i -jO.09",J .~ " p, '--1""-'0 i l I i -, II ' i 0 ' I j', i I <of- : ~O-U~!'-I- ~---l------!I-.--'---t'(yol'-l ~ I : ct...- 1 I '! .-"-----\ 0 'I I ......... , I", ___ ' I l~uJI___~ L-+-- r-Tt"L i \J~. MO~VOO.__:.;.. -::-:.-;;- -- -I" :. 'I 0 nn Ouu , . I, '0 'j-' l II I ~i_Jr- ---- \'<f6--1 ~ : I ---I--~\ t I _L__----;--_ '" I , ,____, ...-+------, I I :o."'~ I ~-___ o.t- : !! "--\:.'\.' -'-.. ' L I .. 0 :i o I <of- O:Q -- '0'9' : ----.0.9 6'~1 o N + -0'9 ,t') 'N -<---. i , o co o to + I{) N Igure 7 Alternative 1 Port Ludlow Resort PIa DSEI o N + I{) N o <of- + <of- N o o + <of- N tC I tC C o ...... ......, U C1J \n o to + t') N i :J . ~ Figure 12A - Building Layouts Port Ludlow Resort Plan DSEIS ~~'G>'GlfSJ .....~.. . - .~~ -.- "- ,,", . -- '-~:':i p p DRIVE ..\-16,30 ROAD -\-17,00 -\-17.80 -\-18,50 -\-19.00 R-8 (600) Ludlow Bay Village ARCHITECTONICS DESIGN &: PLANNING CONSULTANTS