HomeMy WebLinkAboutWORKSHOP re EV Charger Grant presentation Washington Electric
Vehicle Charger
Program Grant
(WAEVCP 2023) r-
Y
c,O N
44
i
S�IN�� ,
A
r
Department of Ecology
On December 19, 2022, the
Washington Department of
Ecology updated its Clean Vehicles
Program requiring all new light-
duty vehicles sold in Washington
Meet zero-emission vehicle (ZEV)
standards by 2035.
- 1
fir. . .,.. �
What u I ' es as a
Battery electric vehicles Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles
Plug-in hybrid vehicles with > 50
miles of electric-only range
.. . .
.Jefferson County Courthouse �
• In 2020, a dual port
L2 charger was
8 � I .
IIproject 1� �installed at a ,..._
cost of $18,800 r
• The L2 charger
represented over
$15,000 of the total -
project costs.
N
Washington Electric
Vehicle Charger • Initial applications submitted 12/1/23 for
Program Grant Jefferson County Courthouse and Castle
g Hill locations. Conditional award 2/28/24.
. � • 20 Level 2 dualport) or 40 single ports,
plus 6 stub-outs.
• Contract signed between lead applicant
(Clean and Prosperous Institute) and the
State on Aug. 9, 2024. Required
f
completion by May 6, 2025.
• Award provides $306K in grant funding,
requires a 25% match ($102,000).
r
Jefferson County Fleet Consideration
• Approximately 100 light and
medium vehicles that fall under ,
the WA Clean Vehicle Program. ,
• 53 vehicles have a scheduled
replacement date that has
expired or will expire by
December 31.
• Electrification of the Fleet has
already begun. O O
Electric Vehicle Authorizations
• Mustang Mach E • Department of Enterprise
Services price comparison
• 98KW battery
• 14Hour charge time from 0% 2023 Mustang Mach E
battery using a 7KW Charger. approximately $10,009 more than
2024 Ford Edge.
• Ford Lightning Pickup 2025 F-150 Lightning
approximately $10,800 more than
• 131 KW Battery comparably equipped 2025 F-150
• 18.7 hour charge time from 0% crew cab.
battery using a 7KW charger. Lightning was equipped with
upgraded 131 KW battery.
WAEVCP 2023 Implementation Options
_ r
•
WAEVCP 2023 Option 1
• Accept the award and move forward with installing all or some of
the allotted 40 L2 ports and 6 stubs.
• Requires 25% Match up to $102,000.
• Considerable unknown construction costs (Site excavation, transformers, new
service establishment, electrical, etc.)
• Currently unbudgeted and unscheduled capital project.
• May 6, 2025 deadline is very difficult to meet.
• Jefferson County would be charged at the PUD rate (projected at 11 cents per
kWh)
WAEVCP 2023 Option 2
• Amend the existing contract with EVCS, allowing them to take on the
burden of installing the L2 ports with the County acting as the site host in
a signed LOI.
• EVCS responsible for installing, maintaining L2 ports while Jefferson County
acts as the site host.
• EVCS responsible for data reporting in compliance with grant requirements.
• EVCS retains ownership of equipment at the end of the contract.
• EVCS recoups cost through utilization of charging ports at a rate of 29 cents
per kWh.
Estimating Charging Costs Using EVCS Rate
----F
Price/kWh 1� #Vehicles Price/Charge of EV Fleet
$0.29 4 $21.69 100 $2,169.20 $99,704.82
$0.29 8 $43.38 100 $4,338.40 $95,492.40
$0.29 12 $65.08 100 $6,507.60 $88,984.80
$0.29 16 $86.77 100 $8,676.80 $80,308.00
$0.29 20 $108.46 100 $10,846.00 $69,462.00
$0.29 24 $130.15 100 $13,015.20 $56,446.80
$0.29 28 $151.84 100 $15,184.40 $41,262.40
$0.29 32 $173.54 100 $17,353.60 $23,908.80
• $0.29 36 $195.23 100 $19,522.80 $4,386.00
$0.29 40 $216.92 100 $21,692.00 ($17,306.00)
WAEVCP 2023 Option 3
• Decline the award, this would mean that the County would pay full
price for the installation of L2 chargers along with all associated
costs (Construction, equipment, material, etc.).
• Seek other funding opportunities, or budget as future capital projects.
• Eliminate immediate financial constraints of the grant match requirement.
• Potential long term savings depending on future costs of implementing the
technology.
• Prevents 10 year contractual obligation related to the EV Charger stations.
• Requires addressing the immediate charging needs of electric vehicles already
purchased.
Estimating Variance in ChargingCosts
#Vehicles Price/Charge of the Price/Charge of the Variance per Total at$0.29 Total at $0.11 Annual
EV Fleet at .29 EV Fleet at .11 charge per kWh per kWh2 Variance
4 $21.69 $8.23 $13.46 $2,169.20 $822.80 $1,346.40
8 $43.38 $16.46 $26.93 $4,338.40 $1,645.60 $2,692.80
12 $65.08 $24.68 $40.39 $6,507.60 $2,468.40 $4,039.20
16 $86.77 $32.91 $53.86 $8,676.80 $3,291.20 $5,385.60
20 $108.46 $41.14 $67.32 $10,846.00 $4,114.00 $6,732.00
24 $130.15 $49.37 $80.78 $13,015.20 $4,936.80 $8,078.40
28 $151.84 $57.60 $94.25 $15,184.40 $5,759.60 $9,424.80
32 $173.54 $65.82 $107.71 $17,353.60 $6,582.40 $10,771.20
36 $195.23 $74.05 $121.18 $19,522.80 $7,405.20 $12,117.60
40 $216.92 $82.28 $134.64 $21,692.00 $8,228.00 $13,464.00
Summary
• WAEVCP 2023 provides funding for 40 L2 ports for the Jefferson
County workforce.
• Upfront costs, timeline, and potential unknown costs present
challenges for implementation.
• The County has contracted with EVCS for other EV charging station
grant awards.
• The WAEVCP decision should be incorporated into a broader
discussion on increasing zero emission vehicles in the Jefferson
County fleet.